Hajji A, Deffieux X
Service de gynécologie-obstétrique et médecine de la reproduction, hôpital Antoine-Béclère, groupe hospitalier universitaire Paris Sud, Assistance publique-Hôpitaux de Paris, 157, rue de la Porte-de-Trivaux, 92140 Clamart, France.
Service de gynécologie-obstétrique et médecine de la reproduction, hôpital Antoine-Béclère, groupe hospitalier universitaire Paris Sud, Assistance publique-Hôpitaux de Paris, 157, rue de la Porte-de-Trivaux, 92140 Clamart, France.
Prog Urol. 2016 Sep;26(10):547-52. doi: 10.1016/j.purol.2016.01.002. Epub 2016 Jan 29.
The subjects presented at scientific congresses often remain confidential because of the non-indexation of the communications. A subsequent publication is necessary for the dissemination of knowledge. The value of a congress is somehow rated by the level of its publications.
To analyze, quantitatively and qualitatively, the fate of the communications presented orally at the annual meeting of the SIFUD-PP between 2006 and 2012.
From the authors' names and the title of the communications presented orally at congresses between 2006 and 2012, we investigated if those communications had resulted as an indexed publication PubMed/Medline until April 2015. We studied anonymously the correlation between the data presented in the communication provided at the SIFUD-PP congress and the data published in the final article. We evaluated the "value" of the publication according to the language of publication (French/English), the ranking of the magazine (A or B versus others), and the number of citations of the article in Google-Scholar.
A total of 270 oral communications were presented at the SIFUD congress between 2006 and 2012, so an average of 38.5 (±15) per year. Globally, 110 articles (40%) have been published in an indexed journal PubMed/MedLine to date (April 2015). Note that 10 articles of the oral communications (8%) were published before the congress. The average time of publication was 22 months±15 months. In terms of the language of publication, 79 articles (71%) were published in English magazines. They were published in 31 different journals (49 articles [44%] in urology, 14 articles [12%] in gynecology, 12 articles [10%] in urogynecology, 11 articles [10%] in coloproctology, 16 articles [14%] in neuro-urology and physical medicine and rehabilitation, 3 articles [2%] in sexology). Sixty-three articles (57%) were published in journals with an impact factor (IF) higher than 2 and 39 articles (35%) were published in journals of rank A or B.
The rate of publications of oral communications varies according to specialties and the type of the congress. For example, the rate of the published communications at the ICS Congress (International Continence Society) in 2003 was 61% and of the AFU (French Association of Urology) in 2000, was 34.5%. The rate of publication of the oral abstracts presented at the SIFUD (40% over the period 2006-2012) is comparable to other national congresses but slightly inferior to those of international congresses. Several hypotheses may explain the non-publication of the oral communications (quitting the project, communication about preliminary results, refused publication by many journals) and unfortunately we do not have those results. We should get back individually to the submitters to know the reasons for non-publication of their works.
In the end, 40% of the oral communication presented at the annual congress of the SIFUD were published in an indexed journals PubMed/MedLine. Seventy-one percent of them are in English.
由于会议交流内容未被索引，在科学大会上展示的主题通常处于保密状态。后续发表文章对于知识传播而言是必要的。某种程度上，大会的价值是由其发表文章的水平来衡量的。
定量和定性分析2006年至2012年间在SIFUD - PP年会上口头交流内容的后续情况。
根据2006年至2012年在大会上口头交流的作者姓名和主题，调查截至2015年4月这些交流内容是否已成为被PubMed/Medline索引的出版物。我们匿名研究了SIFUD - PP大会上交流所提供的数据与最终发表文章中数据之间的相关性。我们根据发表语言（法语/英语）、杂志排名（A或B类与其他）以及文章在谷歌学术上的被引用次数来评估出版物的“价值”。
2006年至2012年间SIFUD大会共进行了270次口头交流，平均每年38.5次（±标准差15次）。总体而言，截至2015年4月，已有110篇文章（40%）在被索引的PubMed/MedLine期刊上发表。注意，10篇口头交流文章（8%）在大会之前就已发表。平均发表时间为22个月±15个月。在发表语言方面，79篇文章（71%）发表于英文杂志。它们发表在31种不同期刊上（49篇[44%]发表于泌尿学领域，14篇[12%]发表于妇科领域，12篇[10%]发表于女性盆底泌尿学领域，11篇[10%]发表于结直肠外科学领域，16篇[14%]发表于神经泌尿学及物理医学与康复领域，3篇[2%]发表于性学领域）。63篇文章（57%）发表于影响因子（IF）高于2的期刊，39篇文章（35%）发表于A类或B类期刊。
口头交流的发表率因专业和大会类型而异。例如，2003年国际尿失禁学会（ICS）大会上交流内容的发表率为61%，2000年法国泌尿外科学会（AFU）大会上的发表率为34.5%。2006 - 2012年期间SIFUD大会上口头摘要的发表率（40%）与其他国内大会相当，但略低于国际大会。有几个假设可以解释口头交流内容未发表的原因（放弃项目、关于初步结果的交流、被多家期刊拒绝发表），遗憾的是我们没有这些结果。我们应该分别联系提交者以了解其作品未发表的原因。
最终，在SIFUD年会上进行的口头交流中有40%在被索引的PubMed/MedLine期刊上发表。其中71%为英文发表。
4级。
