Stowe Julia, Andrews Nicholas, Kosky Christopher, Dennis Gary, Eriksson Sofia, Hall Andrew, Leschziner Guy, Reading Paul, Shneerson John M, Donegan Katherine, Miller Elizabeth
Research Fellow, Public Health England, London, UK.
Senior Statistician, Public Health England, London, UK.
Sleep. 2016 May 1;39(5):1051-7. doi: 10.5665/sleep.5752.
An increased risk of narcolepsy has been observed in children following ASO3-adjuvanted pandemic A/H1N1 2009 (Pandemrix) vaccine. We investigated whether this risk extends to adults in England.
Six adult sleep centers in England were visited between November 2012 and February 2014 and vaccination/clinical histories obtained from general practitioners. Suspected narcolepsy cases aged older than 17 y were selected. The risk of narcolepsy following Pandemrix was calculated using cases diagnosed by the time of the center visits and those with a diagnosis by November 30, 2011 after which there was increased awareness of the risk in children. The odds of vaccination in cases and in matched population data were compared using a case-coverage design.
Of 1,446 possible cases identified, most had onset before 2009 or were clearly not narcolepsy. Of the 60 remaining cases, 20 were excluded after expert review, leaving 40 cases with narcolepsy; 5 had received Pandemrix between 3 and 18 mo before onset. All the vaccinated cases had cataplexy, two received a diagnosis by November 2011 and two were aged 40 y or older. The odds ratio for vaccination in cases compared to the population was 4.24 (95% confidence interval 1.45-12.38) using all cases and 9.06 (1.90-43.17) using cases with a diagnosis by November 2011, giving an attributable risk of 0.59 cases per 100,000 doses.
We found a significantly increased risk of narcolepsy in adults following Pandemrix vaccination in England. The risk was lower than that seen in children using a similar study design.
在接种含ASO3佐剂的2009年甲型H1N1流感大流行疫苗(帕兰朵)后的儿童中,发作性睡病风险有所增加。我们调查了这种风险在英国成年人中是否也存在。
2012年11月至2014年2月期间走访了英国的六个成人睡眠中心,并从全科医生处获取了疫苗接种/临床病史。选取了年龄大于17岁的疑似发作性睡病病例。使用在各中心走访时已确诊的病例以及在2011年11月30日前确诊的病例(自该时间点起儿童发作性睡病风险受到更多关注)来计算接种帕兰朵后发作性睡病的风险。采用病例对照设计比较病例组和匹配的人群数据中接种疫苗的几率。
在1446例可能的病例中,大多数在2009年之前发病或显然不是发作性睡病。在其余60例病例中,经专家审查后排除了20例,剩下40例发作性睡病病例;其中5例在发病前3至18个月接种了帕兰朵。所有接种疫苗的病例均有猝倒症状,2例在2011年11月前确诊,2例年龄在40岁及以上。使用所有病例时,病例组与人群相比接种疫苗的比值比为4.24(95%置信区间1.45 - 12.38),使用在2011年11月前确诊的病例时为9.06(1.90 - 43.17),每10万剂的归因风险为0.59例。
我们发现英国成年人接种帕兰朵疫苗后发作性睡病风险显著增加。使用类似研究设计时,该风险低于儿童中的风险。