Teaford M F, Robinson J G
Department of Cell Biology and Anatomy, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland 21205.
Am J Phys Anthropol. 1989 Nov;80(3):391-401. doi: 10.1002/ajpa.1330800312.
Dental microwear analyses have raised new hopes and questions for functional morphologists. One hope is that analyses will allow insights into subtle dietary differences of extinct species. One major question is whether seasonal and/or habitat differences in dental microwear are reliably detectable. The extensive collections of Cebus nigrivittatus obtained by the Smithsonian Venezuelan Project allowed us to examine seasonal and habitat differences in dental microwear. Specimens were collected from three distinct ecological life zones that are distinguished by both the amount of rainfall and its seasonability. Environmental variation is generally correlated with variation in resource availability which, in C. nigrivittatus, affects diet. Published field studies indicate that these animals depend more on dry hard fruit and chitinous invertebrates during drier times and succulent fruits and caterpillars during wetter times of the year. As in previous microwear analyses, epoxy replicas were prepared from dental impressions, and the replicas were examined under a scanning electron microscope. Two micrographs were taken of facet 9 on M2 of each specimen. Mean values for the proportion of pits (vs. scratches), pit width, and scratch width were computed for each of 62 individuals and compared between ecological zones and collecting dates by using a multiple comparison test. Results indicate that, while seasonal differences in molar microwear in C. nigrivittatus are perhaps reliably detectable, 1) they are small in magnitude, 2) they are only detectable in certain ecological life zones, and 3) they are not of the order of magnitude that will obscure major interspecific differences in molar microwear such as those between C. apella and C. nigrivittatus.
牙齿微磨损分析为功能形态学家带来了新的希望和问题。一个希望是,分析将有助于深入了解已灭绝物种细微的饮食差异。一个主要问题是,牙齿微磨损的季节性和/或栖息地差异是否能够可靠地检测到。史密森尼委内瑞拉项目收集的大量黑纹绒毛猴标本使我们能够研究牙齿微磨损的季节性和栖息地差异。标本采集自三个不同的生态生活区域,这些区域的区别在于降雨量及其季节性。环境变化通常与资源可用性的变化相关,而在黑纹绒毛猴中,这会影响其饮食。已发表的野外研究表明,这些动物在一年中较干燥的时期更多地依赖干硬果实和含甲壳素的无脊椎动物,而在较湿润的时期则依赖多汁果实和毛虫。与之前的微磨损分析一样,从牙齿印模制备环氧树脂复制品,并在扫描电子显微镜下检查这些复制品。对每个标本的M2上的第9小面拍摄两张显微照片。计算了62个个体中每个个体的凹坑(与划痕相比)比例、凹坑宽度和划痕宽度的平均值,并通过多重比较检验在生态区域和采集日期之间进行比较。结果表明,虽然黑纹绒毛猴臼齿微磨损的季节性差异可能可以可靠地检测到,但1)差异程度较小,2)仅在某些生态生活区域可检测到,3)差异程度不会掩盖臼齿微磨损的主要种间差异,例如阿氏绒毛猴和黑纹绒毛猴之间的差异。