Naini Farhad B, Cobourne Martyn T, Garagiola Umberto, McDonald Fraser, Wertheim David
Kingston and St George's Hospitals and St George's Medical School, London, UK.
King's College London Dental Institute, London, UK.
J Craniomaxillofac Surg. 2016 Apr;44(4):446-52. doi: 10.1016/j.jcms.2016.01.010. Epub 2016 Jan 14.
A quantitative evaluation of the influence of the nasofacial angle on perceived attractiveness and threshold values of desire for rhinoplasty.
The nasofacial angle of an idealized silhouette male Caucasian/white profile image was altered incrementally between 21° and 48°. Images were rated on a Likert scale by pretreatment patients (n = 75), laypersons (n = 75), and clinicians (n = 35).
A nasofacial angle of approximately 30° was deemed to be ideal, with a range of 27°-36° deemed acceptable. Angles above or below this range were perceived as unattractive. Angles outside the range of 21°-42° were deemed very unattractive. Excessive nasal prominence (nasofrontal angle of 48°) was deemed the least attractive. In terms of threshold values of desire for surgery, for all groups a threshold value of ≥39° and ≤24° indicated a preference for surgery, with clinicians least likely to suggest surgery. The patient group assessments demonstrated the greatest variability, stressing the importance of using patients as observers, as well as laypersons and clinicians, in facial attractiveness research.
It is recommended that in rhinoplasty planning, the range of normal variability of the nasofrontal angle, in terms of observer acceptance, is taken into account, as well as threshold values of desire for surgery.
对面鼻角对感知吸引力及隆鼻手术期望阈值的影响进行定量评估。
将理想化侧面男性白种人轮廓图像的面鼻角在21°至48°之间逐步改变。由术前患者(n = 75)、外行人(n = 75)和临床医生(n = 35)采用李克特量表对图像进行评分。
约30°的面鼻角被认为是理想的,27° - 36°的范围被认为是可接受的。超出此范围的角度被视为不具吸引力。21° - 42°范围之外的角度被认为非常不具吸引力。鼻过度突出(鼻额角为48°)被认为最不具吸引力。就手术期望阈值而言,对于所有组,≥39°和≤24°的阈值表明倾向于手术,临床医生最不可能建议手术。患者组的评估显示出最大的变异性,强调了在面部吸引力研究中使用患者以及外行人与临床医生作为观察者的重要性。
建议在隆鼻手术规划中,考虑到观察者接受度方面鼻额角正常变异的范围以及手术期望阈值。