Mozumdar Arupendra, Liguori Gary
a Population Council.
b University of Tennessee at Chattanooga.
Res Q Exerc Sport. 2016;87(1):47-58. doi: 10.1080/02701367.2015.1124971.
Estimating obesity prevalence using self-reported height and weight is an economic and effective method and is often used in national surveys. However, self-reporting of height and weight can involve misreporting of those variables and has been found to be associated to the size of the individual. This study investigated the biases in self-reporting of height and weight in the U.S. adult population and generated age-adjusted correction equations for self-reported height and weight separately for each ethnic group's specific height and weight quartile sample. Validity of the body mass index (BMI) classification calculated from corrected self-reported height and weight was also examined.
Data on self-reporting and direct measurement of height and weight from National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey 1999-2008 were analyzed. The final sample included 11,521 men and 10,905 nonpregnant women who were all U.S. citizens aged 20 years or older.
A variation in misreporting of self-reported height and weight depended on the gender, ethnicity, age, and size of the individual. The results from sensitivity and specificity analyses showed that the BMI calculated from corrected values of self-reported height and weight provided more accurate estimations of overweight and obesity than did BMI calculated from self-reported height and weight.
In spite of some methodological concerns, the correction equation of self-reported height and weight generated in this study can be utilized as a method for quick assessment of estimating the obesity and overweight prevalence in the U.S. adult population.
使用自我报告的身高和体重来估计肥胖患病率是一种经济有效的方法,常用于全国性调查。然而,自我报告身高和体重可能会涉及这些变量的误报,并且已发现其与个体的体型有关。本研究调查了美国成年人群体中自我报告身高和体重的偏差,并针对每个种族特定的身高和体重四分位数样本分别生成了年龄调整后的自我报告身高和体重校正方程。还检验了根据校正后的自我报告身高和体重计算出的体重指数(BMI)分类的有效性。
分析了1999 - 2008年国家健康与营养检查调查中自我报告以及直接测量身高和体重的数据。最终样本包括11521名男性和10905名非孕女性,他们均为20岁及以上的美国公民。
自我报告身高和体重的误报差异取决于个体的性别、种族、年龄和体型。敏感性和特异性分析结果表明,根据自我报告身高和体重的校正值计算出的BMI比根据自我报告身高和体重计算出的BMI能更准确地估计超重和肥胖情况。
尽管存在一些方法学上的问题,但本研究中生成的自我报告身高和体重校正方程可作为一种快速评估美国成年人群体肥胖和超重患病率的方法。