Baiocchi Gian Luca, Mazzarri Giancarlo, Totaro Luigi, Missale Guido, Gheza Federico, Morone Mario, Frittol Barbara, Moneghini Dario, Tiberio Guido, Molfino Sarah, Graziol Luigi, Portolani Nazario
Ann Ital Chir. 2015;86:532-8.
To determine the diagnostic accuracy of CT-colonography (CTC) for colorectal nonpolypoid lesions.
In the period 2010-2011, 51 out of 454 patients undergoing CTC received also optical colonoscopy (OC). Three human readers with high, intermediate and low expertise interpreted the images. Flat lesions were defined as 3 mm or less in height; laterally spreading type (LST) lesions were defined as nonpolypoid lesions with more than 10 mm lateral diameter.
A total of 75 nonpolypoid colorectal lesions were identified in 21 patients: 43 type II-A low-grade adenomas, 2 type II-c Tis adenocarcinomas, 2 LST Tis adenocarcinomas, 24 nonadenomatous (hyperplastic) lesions and 4 LST infiltrating tumors (T1N0M0 in 2 cases and T2N0M0 in 2 cases). Per-lesion sensitivity and NPV were 44% and 80.5%, while per-patient sensitivity, specificity, PPV, NPV and accuracy were 80.9%, 93.7%, 89.5%, 88.2%, 88.7%. The readers with high and intermediate experience yielded significantly better diagnostic performances than reader with low experience (p =0.072 and p=0.030). All the infiltrating carcinomas and 75% of tis carcinomas were detected by all the readers.
CTC showed a low per-lesion and an high per-patient diagnostic accuracy for all nonpolypoid colorectal lesions, but an high ability to detect nonpolypoid colorectal carcinomas. Diagnostic performances are strictly related to the reader experience.
Adenoma, Colon cancer, Colonoscopy CT colonography, Non polypoid lesions, Screening.
确定CT结肠成像(CTC)对结直肠非息肉样病变的诊断准确性。
在2010年至2011年期间,454例行CTC检查的患者中有51例同时接受了光学结肠镜检查(OC)。由三名专业水平高、中、低的阅片者解读图像。扁平病变定义为高度3mm及以下;侧向扩散型(LST)病变定义为直径超过10mm的非息肉样病变。
21例患者共发现75个结直肠非息肉样病变:43例II - A型低级别腺瘤、2例II - c型Tis腺癌、2例LST Tis腺癌、24例非腺瘤性(增生性)病变和4例LST浸润性肿瘤(2例为T1N0M0,2例为T2N0M0)。按病变计算的敏感性和阴性预测值分别为44%和80.5%,而按患者计算的敏感性、特异性、阳性预测值、阴性预测值和准确性分别为80.9%、93.7%、89.5%、88.2%、88.7%。经验丰富和中等的阅片者的诊断表现明显优于经验不足的阅片者(p = 0.072和p = 0.030)。所有阅片者均检测到了所有浸润性癌和75%的Tis癌。
CTC对所有结直肠非息肉样病变按病变计算的诊断准确性较低,按患者计算的诊断准确性较高,但对结直肠非息肉样癌具有较高的检测能力。诊断表现与阅片者经验密切相关。
腺瘤;结肠癌;结肠镜检查;CT结肠成像;非息肉样病变;筛查