Sajedi Payam I, Mitchell Jason, Herskovits Edward H, Raghavan Prashant
University of Maryland Medical Center, Baltimore, Maryland.
University of Maryland Medical Center, Baltimore, Maryland.
J Am Coll Radiol. 2016 Apr;13(4):429-34. doi: 10.1016/j.jacr.2015.11.012. Epub 2016 Feb 19.
Electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) is generally contraindicated in patients with intracranial mass lesions or in the presence of increased intracranial pressure. The purpose of this study was to determine the prevalence of incidental abnormalities on routine cross-sectional head imaging, including CT and MRI, that would preclude subsequent ECT.
This retrospective study involved a review of the electronic medical records of 105 patients (totaling 108 imaging studies) between April 27, 2007, and March 20, 2015, referred for cranial CT or MRI with the primary indication of pre-ECT evaluation. The probability of occurrence of imaging findings that would preclude ECT was computed. A cost analysis was also performed on the practice of routine pre-ECT imaging.
Of the 105 patients who presented with the primary indication of ECT clearance (totaling 108 scans), 1 scan (0.93%) revealed findings that precluded ECT. None of the studies demonstrated findings that indicated increased intracranial pressure. A cost analysis revealed that at least $18,662.70 and 521.97 relative value units must be expended to identify one patient with intracranial pathology precluding ECT.
The findings of this study demonstrate an extremely low prevalence of findings that preclude ECT on routine cross-sectional head imaging. The costs incurred in identifying a potential contraindication are high. The authors suggest that the performance of pre-ECT neuroimaging be driven by the clinical examination.
电休克治疗(ECT)通常禁用于患有颅内占位性病变或颅内压升高的患者。本研究的目的是确定常规横断面头部成像(包括CT和MRI)上偶然出现的异常情况的发生率,这些异常情况会排除后续的ECT治疗。
这项回顾性研究涉及对2007年4月27日至2015年3月20日期间105例患者(共108次成像检查)的电子病历进行回顾,这些患者因ECT术前评估的主要指征而接受头颅CT或MRI检查。计算了排除ECT的成像结果出现的概率。还对常规ECT术前成像的实践进行了成本分析。
在以ECT清除为主要指征的105例患者(共108次扫描)中,1次扫描(0.93%)显示出排除ECT的结果。没有一项研究显示有提示颅内压升高的结果。成本分析显示,为识别一名有颅内病变而排除ECT的患者,至少必须花费18,662.70美元和521.97个相对价值单位。
本研究结果表明,在常规横断面头部成像上排除ECT的结果发生率极低。识别潜在禁忌症的成本很高。作者建议,ECT术前神经成像的实施应以临床检查为依据。