Altamura A C, Colacurcio F, Mauri M C, De Vanna M, Rigamonti R, Maj M, Veltro F, Pancheri P, Delle Chiaie R, Porta M
Minerva Psichiatr. 1989 Jul-Sep;30(3):159-64.
Quazepam (QZP), a new long half-life benzodiazepine, seems to have a more specific hypnotic activity and a "physiological" mechanism of action. This study assessed its clinical efficacy and any withdrawal symptoms occurring after the treatment with QZP and triazolam (TRZ). Sixty-five patients (mean age 41.4 yrs +/- 12.43 SD) with sleep disorders were included in the study. The patients were treated with placebo for 4 days (run-in period) and if no amelioration of insomnia was observed, were then randomly allocated to 15 mg QZP (33 patients) or TRZ (32 patients) for 8 weeks and finally placebo for another week. Sleep quality, efficiency, side-effects and withdrawal effects were assessed by specific rating scales. In comparing data obtained from the two treatments, the following conclusions were drawn: 1) both drugs showed a hypnoinductive efficacy but patients treated with QZP had significantly fewer night awakenings; 2) at the end of treatment only patients treated with TRZ had longer awakenings and rebound symptoms; 3) a lower withdrawal symptom incidence was observed in patients treated with QZP. Therefore, QZP seems to have a good hypnotic effect without inducing withdrawal symptoms. In contrast TRZ turned out to be a merely hypno-inducing drug presenting higher risks of rebound effects after withdrawal.
夸西泮(QZP)是一种新型的长半衰期苯二氮䓬类药物,似乎具有更特异的催眠活性和“生理性”作用机制。本研究评估了其临床疗效以及使用QZP和三唑仑(TRZ)治疗后出现的任何戒断症状。65例睡眠障碍患者(平均年龄41.4岁±12.43标准差)纳入本研究。患者先接受4天安慰剂治疗(导入期),若未观察到失眠改善,则随机分为两组,分别接受15mg QZP治疗(33例患者)或TRZ治疗(32例患者),为期8周,最后再接受1周安慰剂治疗。通过特定的评分量表评估睡眠质量、效率、副作用和戒断效应。比较两种治疗获得的数据后,得出以下结论:1)两种药物均显示出诱导睡眠的疗效,但接受QZP治疗的患者夜间觉醒次数明显较少;2)治疗结束时,只有接受TRZ治疗的患者觉醒时间更长且出现反跳症状;3)接受QZP治疗的患者戒断症状发生率较低。因此,QZP似乎具有良好的催眠效果且不会诱发戒断症状。相比之下,TRZ仅仅是一种诱导睡眠的药物,停药后出现反跳效应的风险更高。