Caroli Eve, Weber-Baghdiguian Lexane
PSL, University Paris Dauphine, LEDa-LEGOS, Paris School of Economics and IZA, France.
PSL, University Paris Dauphine, LEDa-LEGOS, France.
Soc Sci Med. 2016 Mar;153:220-9. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2016.02.023. Epub 2016 Feb 17.
The role of social norms in accounting for the different attitudes of men and women with respect to health is still an open issue. In this research, we investigate the role of social norms associated with specific gender environments in the workplace in accounting for differences in health-reporting behaviours across men and women. Using the 2010 European Working Conditions Survey, we build a database containing 30,124 observations. We first replicate the standard result that women report worse health than men, whatever the health outcome we consider. We then proxy social norms by the gender structure of the workplace environment and study how the latter affects self-reported health for men and women separately. Our findings indicate that individuals in workplaces where women are a majority tend to report worse health than individuals employed in male-dominated work environments, be they men or women. These results are robust to controlling for a large array of working condition indicators, which allows us to rule out that the poorer health status reported by individuals working in female-dominated environments could be due to worse job quality. This evidence suggests that social norms associated with specific gender environments play an important role in explaining differences in health-reporting behaviours across gender, at least in the workplace.
社会规范在解释男性和女性对健康的不同态度方面所起的作用仍是一个悬而未决的问题。在本研究中,我们调查了与工作场所特定性别环境相关的社会规范在解释男性和女性健康报告行为差异方面所起的作用。利用2010年欧洲工作条件调查,我们构建了一个包含30124条观测数据的数据库。我们首先复制了标准结果,即无论我们考虑何种健康结果,女性报告的健康状况都比男性差。然后,我们用工作场所环境的性别结构来代表社会规范,并分别研究其对男性和女性自我报告健康状况的影响。我们的研究结果表明,在女性占多数的工作场所中的个体往往比在男性主导的工作环境中工作的个体(无论男女)报告的健康状况更差。这些结果在控制了大量工作条件指标后依然稳健,这使我们能够排除在女性主导环境中工作的个体报告的较差健康状况可能是由于工作质量较差所致。这一证据表明,与特定性别环境相关的社会规范在解释不同性别之间健康报告行为的差异方面起着重要作用,至少在工作场所是如此。