Tompson A C, Petit-Zeman S, Goldacre B, Heneghan C J
Nuffield Department of Primary Care Health Sciences, The Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK.
National Institute of Health Research Oxford Biomedical Research Centre and Unit, Oxford University Hospitals NHS Trust, Oxford, UK.
BMJ Open. 2016 Mar 2;6(3):e009285. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2015-009285.
To audit the proportion of clinical trials that had been publically registered and, of the completed trials, the proportion published.
2 major research institutions supported by the National Institute of Health Research (NIHR).
The proportion of trials reporting results within 12 months, 24 months and 'ever'. Factors associated with non-publication were analysed using logistic regression.
Phases 2-4 clinical trials identified from internal documents and publication lists.
In total, 286 trials were identified. We could not find registration for 4 (1.4%) of these, all of which were completed and published. Of the trials with a registered completion date pre-January 2015, just over half (56%) were published, and half of these were published within 12 months (36/147, 25%). For some trials, information on the public registers was found to be out-of-date and/or inaccurate. No clinical trial characteristics were found to be significantly associated with non-publication. We have produced resources to facilitate similar audits elsewhere.
It was feasible to conduct an internal audit of registration and publication in 2 major research institutions. Performance was similar to, or better than, comparable cohorts of trials sampled from registries. The major resource input required was manually seeking information: if all registry entries were maintained, then almost the entire process of audit could be automated--and routinely updated--for all research centres and funders.
审核已公开注册的临床试验比例,以及已完成试验的发表比例。
由英国国家卫生研究院(NIHR)资助的2家主要研究机构。
在12个月、24个月及“任何时间”内报告结果的试验比例。使用逻辑回归分析与未发表相关的因素。
从内部文件和发表列表中识别出的2-4期临床试验。
共识别出286项试验。其中4项(1.4%)未找到注册信息,所有这些试验均已完成并发表。在注册完成日期早于2015年1月的试验中,略超过一半(56%)已发表,其中一半在12个月内发表(36/147,25%)。对于一些试验,发现公共注册信息过时和/或不准确。未发现任何临床试验特征与未发表有显著关联。我们已制作相关资源以方便其他地方进行类似审核。
在2家主要研究机构对注册和发表情况进行内部审核是可行的。表现与从注册库中抽取的同类试验队列相似或更好。所需的主要资源投入是人工查找信息:如果所有注册条目都得到维护,那么几乎整个审核过程都可以为所有研究中心和资助者实现自动化并定期更新。