Giesler Marianne, Boeker Martin, Fabry Götz, Biller Silke
University of Freiburg, Medical Faculty, Office of Student Affairs, Centre for Evaluation of Teaching in Medicine Baden-Württemberg, Freiburg, Germany.
University of Freiburg, Medical Faculty, Department for Medical Biometry and Medical Informatics, Freiburg, Germany.
GMS J Med Educ. 2016 Feb 15;33(1):Doc8. doi: 10.3205/zma001007. eCollection 2016.
The majority of medical graduates in Germany complete a doctorate, even though a doctoral degree is not necessary for the practice of medicine. So far, little is known about doctoral candidates' view on the individual benefit a doctoral thesis has for them. Consequently, this is the subject of the present investigation.
Data from surveys with graduates of the five medical faculties of Baden-Württemberg from the graduation years 2007/2008 (N=514) and 2010/2011 (N=598) were analysed.
One and a half years after graduating 53% of those interviewed had completed their doctorate. When asked about their motivation for writing a doctoral thesis, participants answered most frequently "a doctorate is usual" (85%) and "improvement of job opportunities" (75%), 36% said that an academic career has been their primary motive. Less than 10% responded that they used their doctoral thesis as a means to apply for a job. The proportion of graduates working in health care is equally large among those who have completed a thesis and those who have not. Graduates who pursued a thesis due to scientific interest are also currently more interested in an academic career and recognise more opportunities for research. An implicit benefit of a medical thesis emerged with regard to the self-assessment of scientific competences as those who completed a doctorate rated their scientific competencies higher than those who have not.
Although for the majority of physicians research interest is not the primary motivation for completing a doctorate, they might nevertheless achieve some academic competencies. For graduates pursuing an academic career the benefit of completing a medical thesis is more obvious.
在德国,尽管医学博士学位并非行医的必要条件,但大多数医学专业毕业生还是会完成博士学业。到目前为止,对于博士研究生而言,博士论文对他们个人的益处这方面了解甚少。因此,这就是本调查的主题。
对来自巴登 - 符腾堡州五个医学院系2007/2008届(N = 514)和2010/2011届(N = 598)毕业生的调查数据进行了分析。
毕业一年半后,53%的受访者完成了博士学业。当被问及撰写博士论文的动机时,参与者最常回答的是“博士学位很常见”(85%)和“改善就业机会”(75%),36%的人表示学术生涯是他们的主要动机。不到10%的人回答说他们将博士论文用作求职手段。已完成论文和未完成论文的毕业生中,从事医疗保健工作的比例相当。因科学兴趣而撰写论文的毕业生目前对学术生涯也更感兴趣,并且认识到更多的研究机会。关于科学能力的自我评估方面,医学论文有一个潜在益处,即完成博士学位的人对自己科学能力的评价高于未完成博士学位的人。
尽管对于大多数医生来说,研究兴趣并非完成博士学位的主要动机,但他们仍可能获得一些学术能力。对于追求学术生涯的毕业生来说,完成医学论文的益处更为明显。