开放主动脉弓手术当前策略与结果的多中心分析:异质性仍是一个问题。
Multicentre analysis of current strategies and outcomes in open aortic arch surgery: heterogeneity is still an issue.
作者信息
Urbanski Paul P, Luehr Maximilian, Di Bartolomeo Roberto, Diegeler Anno, De Paulis Ruggero, Esposito Giampiero, Bonser Robert S, Etz Christian D, Kallenbach Klaus, Rylski Bartosz, Shrestha Malakh Lal, Tsagakis Konstantinos, Zacher Michael, Zierer Andreas
机构信息
Cardiovascular Clinic Bad Neustadt, Bad Neustadt, Germany
Department of Cardiac Surgery, Ludwig-Maximilians University Munich, Munich, Germany.
出版信息
Eur J Cardiothorac Surg. 2016 Aug;50(2):249-55. doi: 10.1093/ejcts/ezw055. Epub 2016 Mar 16.
OBJECTIVES
The study was conducted to evaluate, on the basis of a multicentre analysis, current results of elective open aortic arch surgery performed during the last decade.
METHODS
Data of 1232 consecutive patients who underwent aortic arch repair with reimplantation of at least one supra-aortic artery between 2004 and 2013 were collected from 11 European cardiovascular centres, and retrospective statistical examination was performed using uni- and multi-variable analyses to identify predictors for 30-day mortality. Acute aortic dissections and arch surgeries not involving the supra-aortic arteries were not included.
RESULTS
Arch repair involving all 3 arch arteries (total), 2 arch arteries (subtotal) or 1 arch artery (partial) was performed in 956 (77.6%), 155 (12.6%) and 121 (9.8%) patients, respectively. The patients' characteristics as well as the surgical techniques, including the method of cannulation, perfusion and protection, varied considerably between the clinics participating in the study. The in-hospital and 30-day mortality rates were 11.4 and 8.8% for the entire cohort, respectively, ranging between 1.7 and 19.0% in the surgical centres. Multivariable logistic regression analysis identified surgical centre, patient's age, number of previous surgeries with sternotomy and concomitant surgeries as independent risk factors of 30-day mortality. The follow-up of the study group was 96.5% complete with an overall follow-up duration of 3.3 ± 2.9 years, resulting in 4020 patient-years. After hospital discharge, 176 (14.3%) patients died, yielding an overall mortality rate of 25.6%. The actuarial survival after 5 and 8 years was 72.0 ± 1.5% and 64.0 ± 2.0, respectively.
CONCLUSIONS
The surgical risk in elective aortic arch surgery has remained high during the last decade despite the advance in surgical techniques. However, the patients' characteristics, numbers of surgeries, the techniques and the results varied considerably among the centres. The incompleteness of data gathered retrospectively was not effective enough to determine advantages of particular cannulation, perfusion, protection or surgical techniques; and therefore, we strongly recommend further prospective multicentre studies, preferably registries, in which all relevant data have to be clearly defined and collected.
目的
本研究旨在通过多中心分析评估过去十年间择期开放性主动脉弓手术的当前结果。
方法
收集了2004年至2013年间在11个欧洲心血管中心接受主动脉弓修复并至少再植一根主动脉弓上动脉的1232例连续患者的数据,并采用单变量和多变量分析进行回顾性统计检查,以确定30天死亡率的预测因素。急性主动脉夹层和不涉及主动脉弓上动脉的弓部手术未纳入。
结果
分别对956例(77.6%)、155例(12.6%)和121例(9.8%)患者进行了涉及所有3根弓动脉(全弓)、2根弓动脉(次全弓)或1根弓动脉(部分弓)的弓部修复。参与研究的各临床中心之间,患者特征以及手术技术(包括插管、灌注和保护方法)差异很大。整个队列的住院死亡率和30天死亡率分别为11.4%和8.8%,各手术中心的死亡率在1.7%至19.0%之间。多变量逻辑回归分析确定手术中心、患者年龄、既往开胸手术次数和同期手术为30天死亡率的独立危险因素。研究组的随访完成率为96.5%,总随访时间为3.3±2.9年,共4020患者年。出院后,176例(14.3%)患者死亡,总死亡率为25.6%。5年和8年的精算生存率分别为72.0±1.5%和64.0±2.0%。
结论
尽管手术技术有所进步,但过去十年间择期主动脉弓手术的手术风险仍然很高。然而,各中心之间患者特征、手术次数、技术和结果差异很大。回顾性收集的数据不完整,不足以有效确定特定插管、灌注、保护或手术技术的优势;因此,我们强烈建议进一步开展前瞻性多中心研究,最好是注册研究,明确界定并收集所有相关数据。