Elsheikh Nabil Ail, Amr Yasser M
Departments of Anesthesiology and Surgical Intensive Care, Faculty of Medicine, Tanta University, Egypt.
Pain Physician. 2016 Mar;19(3):139-46.
BACKGROUND: Spinal canal stenosis is one of the most common causes of low back pain and disability. Its management varies from surgical to conservative, and the indications for ideal management are not clearly defined. OBJECTIVES: This study was conducted to evaluate the effect of adding calcitonin to local anesthetic and corticosteroid in epidural injection for patients suffering from degenerative lumbar spinal canal stenosis. STUDY DESIGN: Randomized double-blind clinical trial. SETTING: Hospital outpatient setting. METHODS: One hundred thirty-two patients with degenerative spinal canal stenosis were randomly allocated into 2 groups. Group I received C-arm guided epidural injection of local anesthetic and corticosteroid and Group II received 50 international unit calcitonin added to the mixture of local anesthetic and corticosteroid. Both groups received 2 sets of injections, one week apart. Visual analogue scale for pain during movement and walking distance until incidence of neurogenic claudication have been used for pain assessment, and Oswestry Low Back Pain Disability Questionnaire and analgesic consumption were evaluated for one year. RESULTS: Both groups showed comparable benefits regarding improvement in pain intensity, walking distance, Oswestry scale, and analgesic consumption during the first month follow-up period. These beneficial effects continued in calcitonin group for one year. LIMITATIONS: The present study patients would be graded as having mild or at worst moderate stenosis. So, the present study did not examine the efficacy of epidural calcitonin in severe spinal canal stenosis and did not stratify the results according to degree of stenosis which would also have been useful in determining the validity of calcitonin in different degrees of stenosis. CONCLUSION: Adding calcitonin to epidural steroid and local anesthetic injection seems to be more effective than epidural steroid and local anesthesia alone in management of spinal canal stenosis regarding increased walking distance, better Oswestry scale, diminished pain intensity and perception of paresthesia, and less analgesic consumption, all the above mentioned benefits continued up to one year. So, epidural calcitonin may be considered as a new therapeutic modality in the management of pain in spinal canal stenosis.
背景:椎管狭窄是腰背痛和残疾的最常见原因之一。其治疗方法从手术到保守治疗各不相同,理想治疗的指征尚未明确界定。 目的:本研究旨在评估在硬膜外注射中添加降钙素至局部麻醉剂和皮质类固醇对退行性腰椎管狭窄患者的疗效。 研究设计:随机双盲临床试验。 地点:医院门诊。 方法:132例退行性椎管狭窄患者被随机分为两组。第一组接受C形臂引导下硬膜外注射局部麻醉剂和皮质类固醇,第二组在局部麻醉剂和皮质类固醇混合物中加入50国际单位降钙素。两组均接受2组注射,间隔1周。使用运动时疼痛视觉模拟量表和直至神经源性间歇性跛行发作的步行距离进行疼痛评估,并对Oswestry腰痛残疾问卷和镇痛药消耗量进行了为期一年的评估。 结果:在第一个月的随访期内,两组在疼痛强度改善、步行距离、Oswestry量表和镇痛药消耗量方面显示出相当的益处。这些有益效果在降钙素组持续了一年。 局限性:本研究中的患者将被分级为轻度或最严重为中度狭窄。因此,本研究未考察硬膜外降钙素在严重椎管狭窄中的疗效,也未根据狭窄程度对结果进行分层,而这对于确定降钙素在不同程度狭窄中的有效性也会很有用。 结论:在硬膜外类固醇和局部麻醉剂注射中添加降钙素,在椎管狭窄的治疗中,似乎比单独使用硬膜外类固醇和局部麻醉更有效,表现为步行距离增加、Oswestry量表改善、疼痛强度减轻和感觉异常感知减少以及镇痛药消耗量减少,上述所有益处持续长达一年。因此,硬膜外降钙素可被视为椎管狭窄疼痛管理中的一种新治疗方式。
Arch Orthop Trauma Surg. 2024-5
Curr Pain Headache Rep. 2019-3-19