Matthews Avery Madeleine, Rosenquist Peter B, McCall William Vaughn
From the Department of Psychiatry and Health Behavior, Augusta University, Augusta, GA.
J ECT. 2016 Sep;32(3):187-91. doi: 10.1097/YCT.0000000000000312.
The aim of the study was to survey the media landscape to determine whether visual depictions of electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) are becoming more or less medically accurate in the new millennium.
English-language film and television shows depicting ECT were analyzed for patient demographics, administrator roles, indication, consent, anesthesia, paralytics, bite block, lead placement, electroencephalogram, and outcome.
Thirty-nine ECT scenes were viewed, and just 3 included all 5 essential tools of modern ECT: anesthesia, paralytic, electrodes, electroencephalogram, and a bite block.
Media depictions of ECT do not reflect current practice. Too often, ECT is portrayed as a torture technique rather than an evidenced-based therapy, and even in a therapeutic setting, it is too often shown with outdated techniques.
本研究旨在调查媒体环境,以确定在新千年中,电休克疗法(ECT)的视觉呈现在医学准确性方面是提高还是降低了。
对描绘ECT的英语电影和电视节目进行分析,内容包括患者人口统计学、管理人员角色、适应症、同意情况、麻醉、麻痹剂、咬块、电极放置、脑电图及治疗结果。
共查看了39个ECT场景,其中只有3个场景包含现代ECT的所有5种基本工具:麻醉、麻痹剂、电极、脑电图和咬块。
媒体对ECT的呈现并未反映当前的实际情况。ECT常常被描绘成一种酷刑技术,而非循证疗法,即便在治疗场景中,也经常展示过时的技术。