Stevenson C M, Dargan D P, Warnock J, Sloan S, Espey R, Maguire S, Eames N
Department of Trauma and Orthopaedic Surgery, The Royal Hospitals, Belfast, Northern Ireland, UK.
Spinal Cord Injury Unit, Musgrave Park Hospital, Belfast, UK.
Spinal Cord. 2016 Nov;54(11):1010-1015. doi: 10.1038/sc.2016.34. Epub 2016 Mar 29.
Retrospective cohort analysis with prospective follow-up.
To evaluate neurological and functional recovery following central cord syndrome.
Northern Ireland, population 1.8 million.
Twenty-seven cords were identified in 1 year. Five managed conservatively and 22 with surgery. American Spinal Injury Association (ASIA) motor scores (AMS) were calculated to assess neurological recovery. Rotterdam scores assessed functional independence at 3 years.
Average age was 62 years. Mechanism of injury was a fall with neck hyperextension in 81% patients. Average AMS in surgical patients improved from injury, preoperatively, postoperatively, 6 months and 3 years from 51, 81, 83, 90 to 96, respectively. Conservative patients improved from time of injury to day 10 from 57 to 86 and then fell to 84 at 6 months. By 3 years, this had recovered to 91. There was no statistical significant difference in AMS (P=0.15)/change in AMS (ΔAMS) (P=0.92) or percentage of motor deficit resolution (P=0.23) between groups at 3 years. Two patients underwent surgery within 48 h and achieved full motor recovery by 3 years, but this was not significant (P=0.2). ASIA score improvement had a positive correlation with age at injury. Patients treated with surgery had better Rotterdam scores at 3 years than those managed conservatively (P=0.05).
This study confirms the natural history of central cord syndrome. Although it demonstrates equivocal neurological recovery for both groups, patients treated with surgery regained a greater degree of functional independence.
回顾性队列分析及前瞻性随访。
评估中央脊髓综合征后的神经和功能恢复情况。
北爱尔兰,人口180万。
1年内共识别出27例脊髓损伤病例。其中5例采用保守治疗,22例接受手术治疗。通过计算美国脊髓损伤协会(ASIA)运动评分(AMS)来评估神经恢复情况。采用鹿特丹评分评估3年后的功能独立性。
患者平均年龄为62岁。81%的患者损伤机制为颈部过伸性跌倒。手术患者的平均AMS评分从受伤时、术前、术后、术后6个月及3年分别为51、81、83、90和96。保守治疗患者从受伤时到第10天AMS评分从57提高到86,然后在6个月时降至84。到3年时,该评分恢复到91。两组在3年时的AMS评分(P=0.15)/AMS变化量(ΔAMS)(P=0.92)或运动功能缺损恢复百分比(P=0.23)无统计学显著差异。2例患者在48小时内接受手术,3年后实现完全运动恢复,但差异无统计学意义(P=0.2)。ASIA评分改善与受伤时年龄呈正相关。手术治疗的患者在3年时的鹿特丹评分优于保守治疗患者(P=0.05)。
本研究证实了中央脊髓综合征的自然病程。虽然两组神经恢复情况不明确,但手术治疗的患者恢复了更高程度的功能独立性。