Ross Marshall, Selby Sasha, Poonai Naveen, Liu Helena, Minoosepehr Shabnam, Boag Graham, Eccles Robin, Thompson Graham
*Department of Emergency Medicine,University of Calgary,Calgary,AB.
¶Medical Undergraduate at University of Limerick,Limerick,Ireland.
CJEM. 2016 Nov;18(6):414-419. doi: 10.1017/cem.2016.23. Epub 2016 Apr 4.
We examined the effect of a full bladder on proportions of diagnostic ultrasound (US) studies in children with suspected appendicitis. We also examined the effect of a full bladder on proportions of fully visualized ovaries on US in children with suspected appendicitis.
We conducted a retrospective health record review of children aged 2-17 years presenting to a tertiary pediatric emergency department (ED) with suspected appendicitis who had an ultrasound performed. We compared proportions of diagnostic US studies in children with full and sub-optimally filled bladders. We also compared proportions of ovarian visualization in females with full and sub-optimally filled bladders.
678 children were included in our final analysis. The proportion of diagnostic US studies did not vary significantly between groups with a full (132/283, 47%, 95% confidence interval [CI] 38%-56%) or sub-optimally filled bladder (205/395, 52%, 95% CI 47%-57%)(p=0.17). Rates of ovarian visualization were higher in females with a full bladder (196/205, 96%, 95% CI 93%-99%) compared to those with a sub-optimally filled bladder (180/223, 81%, 95% CI 76%-86%) (p<0.01).
Administrators and clinical decision makers should consider removing routine bladder filling practice from current pediatric appendicitis protocols in males and in pre-pubertal females where ovarian pathology is not suspected. Selective bladder filling prior to US should be performed in females when ovarian pathology is suspected.
我们研究了膀胱充盈对疑似阑尾炎儿童诊断性超声(US)检查比例的影响。我们还研究了膀胱充盈对疑似阑尾炎儿童超声检查中卵巢完全可视化比例的影响。
我们对2至17岁因疑似阑尾炎就诊于三级儿科急诊科(ED)并接受超声检查的儿童进行了回顾性健康记录审查。我们比较了膀胱充盈和充盈欠佳的儿童诊断性超声检查的比例。我们还比较了膀胱充盈和充盈欠佳的女性卵巢可视化的比例。
678名儿童纳入我们的最终分析。膀胱充盈(132/283,47%,95%置信区间[CI]38%-56%)或充盈欠佳(205/395,52%,95%CI 47%-57%)的组间诊断性超声检查比例无显著差异(p=0.17)。与膀胱充盈欠佳的女性(180/223,81%,95%CI 76%-86%)相比,膀胱充盈的女性卵巢可视化率更高(196/205,96%,95%CI 93%-99%)(p<0.01)。
对于男性以及未怀疑有卵巢病变的青春期前女性,管理人员和临床决策者应考虑从当前儿科阑尾炎诊疗方案中取消常规膀胱充盈操作。当怀疑有卵巢病变时,女性在超声检查前应选择性地进行膀胱充盈。