Ono Yohei, Kashihara Rina, Yasojima Nobutoshi, Kasahara Hideki, Shimizu Yuka, Tamura Kenichi, Tsutsumi Kaori, Sutherland Kenneth, Koike Takao, Kamishima Tamotsu
1 Department of Radiology, NTT Sapporo Medical Center, Sapporo, Japan.
2 Department of Radiology, Department of Medical Technology, Sunagawa City Medical Center, Sunagawa, Japan.
Br J Radiol. 2016 Jun;89(1062):20150967. doi: 10.1259/bjr.20150967. Epub 2016 Apr 4.
Accurate evaluation of joint space width (JSW) is important in the assessment of rheumatoid arthritis (RA). In clinical radiography of bilateral hands, the oblique incidence of X-rays is unavoidable, which may cause perceptional or measurement error of JSW. The objective of this study was to examine whether tomosynthesis, a recently developed modality, can facilitate a more accurate evaluation of JSW than radiography under the condition of oblique incidence of X-rays.
We investigated quantitative errors derived from the oblique incidence of X-rays by imaging phantoms simulating various finger joint spaces using radiographs and tomosynthesis images. We then compared the qualitative results of the modified total Sharp score of a total of 320 joints from 20 patients with RA between these modalities.
A quantitative error was prominent when the location of the phantom was shifted along the JSW direction. Modified total Sharp scores of tomosynthesis images were significantly higher than those of radiography, that is to say JSW was regarded as narrower in tomosynthesis than in radiography when finger joints were located where the oblique incidence of X-rays is expected in the JSW direction.
Tomosynthesis can facilitate accurate evaluation of JSW in finger joints of patients with RA, even with oblique incidence of X-rays.
Accurate evaluation of JSW is necessary for the management of patients with RA. Through phantom and clinical studies, we demonstrate that tomosynthesis may achieve more accurate evaluation of JSW.
准确评估关节间隙宽度(JSW)在类风湿关节炎(RA)的评估中至关重要。在双手的临床X线摄影中,X线的倾斜入射不可避免,这可能导致JSW的感知或测量误差。本研究的目的是检验断层合成这一最新发展的成像方式在X线倾斜入射条件下是否比X线摄影能更准确地评估JSW。
我们通过使用X线片和断层合成图像对模拟各种手指关节间隙的模型进行成像,研究X线倾斜入射产生的定量误差。然后我们比较了20例RA患者共320个关节的改良总Sharp评分在这两种成像方式下的定性结果。
当模型位置沿JSW方向移动时,定量误差显著。断层合成图像的改良总Sharp评分显著高于X线片,也就是说,当手指关节位于JSW方向预期有X线倾斜入射的位置时,断层合成中JSW被认为比X线片中更窄。
即使存在X线倾斜入射,断层合成也能促进对RA患者手指关节JSW的准确评估。
准确评估JSW对RA患者的管理很有必要。通过模型和临床研究,我们证明断层合成可能实现对JSW更准确的评估。