Shipp Hilts Asante, Mack Stephanie, Eidson Millicent, Nguyen Trang, Birkhead Guthrie S
1Office of Public Health,New York State Department of Health,Albany,New York.
Disaster Med Public Health Prep. 2016 Jun;10(3):308-13. doi: 10.1017/dmp.2015.142. Epub 2015 Dec 2.
Analyzing Hurricane Sandy emergency reports to assess the New York State (NYS) public health system response will help inform and improve future disaster preparedness and response.
Qualitative analysis of NYS Department of Health (NYSDOH) and Nassau and Suffolk County local health department (LHD) emergency reports was conducted. Three after-action reports and 48 situation reports were reviewed, grouped by key words and sorted into 16 Public Health Preparedness Capabilities. Within each capability, key words were labeled as strengths, challenges, or recommendations.
The NYSDOH capability most cited as a strength was successful emergency operations coordination, eg, interagency conference calls (27.4% of 1681 strengths). The most cited challenge was environmental health protection, eg, mold and oil spills (28% of 706 challenges). The LHD capability most cited both as a strength (46.7% of 30 strengths) and as a challenge (32.5% of 123 challenges) was emergency operations coordination. Strengths were exemplified by sharing local resources and challenges by insufficient memorandums of understanding for coordination.
Post-disaster emergency reports should be systematically reviewed to highlight both successes and areas for improvement. Future studies should prioritize collecting feedback from a wider spectrum of public health and service provider staff for planning of preparedness and response activities. (Disaster Med Public Health Preparedness. 2015;10:308-313).
分析飓风桑迪的应急报告以评估纽约州公共卫生系统的应对情况,将有助于为未来的灾难防范和应对提供信息并加以改进。
对纽约州卫生部(NYSDOH)以及拿骚县和萨福克县地方卫生部门(LHD)的应急报告进行定性分析。审查了三份事后分析报告和48份情况报告,按关键词进行分组,并归类为16项公共卫生防范能力。在每项能力中,关键词被标记为优势、挑战或建议。
被提及最多的NYSDOH优势能力是成功的应急行动协调,例如跨部门电话会议(在1681项优势中占27.4%)。被提及最多的挑战是环境卫生保护,例如霉菌和石油泄漏(在706项挑战中占28%)。LHD中被提及最多的优势能力(在30项优势中占46.7%)和挑战能力(在123项挑战中占32.5%)都是应急行动协调。优势体现在共享当地资源方面,而挑战则体现在协调方面的谅解备忘录不足。
应系统地审查灾后应急报告,以突出成功之处和改进领域。未来的研究应优先从更广泛的公共卫生和服务提供人员那里收集反馈,以用于防范和应对活动的规划。(《灾难医学与公共卫生防范》。2015年;10:308 - 313)