Marinović Branka
Acta Dermatovenerol Croat. 2016 Apr;24(1):11-1.
Each year, during the Annual Meeting of the American Academy of Dermatology, there is a meeting of the Council of Dermatology Editors organized by Professor Larry Parish from Philadelphia. It is so nice to meet old friends there and make some new ones, but above all it is a very good platform to discuss the problems journals and their editors are facing today. Some of the topics we discussed during this year's meeting were the increasing number of case reports submitted to all dermatological journals, problems of plagiarism, the rising number of online journals, and the predatory policies quite often connected with them. There was also discussion on print vs online publication versions and on open access journals. It is always useful to discuss common problems, to realize that all journals have similar problems, and to exchange experiences in solving these problems. One of the problems all journals are facing is the increasing number of case reports being submitted, and their high rejection rate due to different reasons. Acta Dermatovenerologica Croatica is overloaded with case reports from many different countries around the world. Most of them are interesting, well prepared cases and could be a good way of exchanging experience between dermatologists. From my personal point of view, case reports are a very useful form of medical communication. For many years they were usually the first articles written by residents under the supervision of their mentors, and I think that all of us should insist on that in the future as well. But the problem is that it has become very difficult to find a journal willing to publish many case reports. Authors are trying to find a journal to publish their case reports in, sometimes sending them to many journals. Unfortunately, the rate of rejection of case reports is rising. And why? There are a few reasons for that, but probably one of the most important is that a high number of published case reports per issue of any journal decreases the impact factor of journal. And for each editor and editorial board, impact factor is one of the main criterions used every year to measure the quality of the journal and their efforts to improve it. Impact factor is also an important criterion when applying for academic positions. This has resulted in some high-impact journals starting to publish separate editions of their journals with case reports only, but also with no or with very low impact factor. This is probably one of the reasons why we receive offers to publish all types of articles in different online open access journals on a daily basis. But of course, if you pay for it… Acta Dermatovenerologica Croatica is proud to be the official journal of the Croatian Dermatovenereological Society of the Croatian Medical Association and also be supported by the Croatian Ministry of Science. This gives us the freedom to make balanced content with some case reports per issue, all for free. But we of course also have to take care and try to increase our impact factor, so we try to encourage authors to publish their interesting case reports in the form of letters to the editor, which do not influence the impact factor so strongly but give us the opportunity to communicate our experiences. During this year we hope to make some improvements in the quality and visibility of our Journal, and to start the 25th anniversary of the journal with new impetus.
每年,在美国皮肤科学会年会期间,都会有一场由来自费城的拉里·帕里什教授组织的皮肤科编辑委员会会议。在那里能见到老朋友并结识新朋友真是太好了,但最重要的是,这是一个讨论期刊及其编辑如今所面临问题的绝佳平台。我们在今年会议期间讨论的一些话题包括提交给所有皮肤科期刊的病例报告数量不断增加、剽窃问题、在线期刊数量的上升以及常常与之相关的掠夺性政策。还讨论了印刷版与网络版出版物以及开放获取期刊的问题。讨论共同问题、意识到所有期刊都有类似问题并交流解决这些问题的经验总是很有用的。所有期刊都面临的一个问题是提交的病例报告数量不断增加,且由于各种原因其拒稿率很高。《克罗地亚皮肤性病学学报》收到了来自世界许多不同国家的大量病例报告。其中大多数都是有趣且准备充分的病例,可能是皮肤科医生之间交流经验的好方式。就我个人而言,病例报告是医学交流的一种非常有用的形式。多年来,它们通常是住院医师在导师指导下撰写的首批文章,我认为我们所有人在未来也应该坚持这一点。但问题是,很难找到愿意发表大量病例报告的期刊。作者们试图找到能发表他们病例报告的期刊,有时会把报告发给很多期刊。不幸的是,病例报告的拒稿率在上升。原因是什么呢?有几个原因,但可能最重要的一个原因是,任何期刊每期发表大量病例报告会降低该期刊的影响因子。对于每位编辑和编辑委员会来说,影响因子是每年用于衡量期刊质量及其提升努力的主要标准之一。在申请学术职位时,影响因子也是一个重要标准。这导致一些高影响力期刊开始出版仅包含病例报告的单独版本,而且这些版本的影响因子很低或没有影响因子。这可能是我们每天都会收到在不同在线开放获取期刊上发表各类文章的邀约的原因之一。但当然,如果你为此付费……《克罗地亚皮肤性病学学报》很自豪成为克罗地亚医学协会克罗地亚皮肤性病学会的官方期刊,并得到克罗地亚科学部的支持。这使我们有自由每期发表一些病例报告来平衡内容,而且全部免费。但我们当然也必须注意并努力提高我们的影响因子,所以我们鼓励作者以给编辑的信的形式发表他们有趣的病例报告,这样对影响因子的影响没那么大,但能让我们有机会交流经验。在这一年里,我们希望在期刊的质量和知名度方面有所改进,并以新的动力开启期刊的第25个周年纪念。