Lee Seung Jin, Cho YoonHee, Song Ji Yeon, Lee DamHee, Kim Yunjung, Kim HyangHee
Graduate Program in Speech and Language Pathology, Yonsei University, Seoul, Korea.
Folia Phoniatr Logop. 2015;67(6):300-7. doi: 10.1159/000445290. Epub 2016 May 5.
This paper sought to examine perceptual and acoustic characteristics in Korean female voices, focusing on the 'breathy' quality as a function of aging. In addition, we aimed to investigate if the three selected measures, H1-H2, H1-A1, and H1-A3, demonstrated any changes along a sustained vowel production.
A total of 42 participants were assigned to two age groups, young women and elderly women. All participants were asked to sustain /a/ as long and as steadily as possible. Perceptual judgments of breathiness were made on the GRBAS scale and by a direct magnitude estimation technique, while three acoustic parameters, H1-H2, H1-A1, and H1-A3, were measured at five measurement time points during the sustained vowel test.
Results indicated that the H1-H2 and H1-A1 values were significantly lower for elderly women compared to young women, although no difference in the perceptual estimation of breathiness was found between the age groups. Among the acoustic measures, only H1-A1 was significantly regressed against the perceptual estimate of breathiness. In addition, no significant acoustic difference in the measures was found across the five measurement points.
Our findings suggest that the aging voice might not be universally characterized by the breathy quality, which hints at the need for further research on ethnic diversity in vocal quality.
本文旨在研究韩国女性嗓音的感知和声学特征,重点关注作为衰老函数的“呼吸声”特质。此外,我们旨在调查所选的三项指标,即H1-H2、H1-A1和H1-A3,在持续元音发音过程中是否呈现出任何变化。
共有42名参与者被分为两个年龄组,年轻女性和老年女性。所有参与者被要求尽可能长时间且稳定地持续发/a/音。对呼吸声的感知判断采用GRBAS量表并通过直接量级估计技术进行,同时在持续元音测试的五个测量时间点测量三个声学参数,即H1-H2、H1-A1和H1-A3。
结果表明,与年轻女性相比,老年女性的H1-H2和H1-A1值显著更低,尽管在不同年龄组之间未发现呼吸声感知估计存在差异。在声学测量中,只有H1-A1与呼吸声的感知估计呈显著回归关系。此外,在五个测量点之间未发现这些测量指标存在显著的声学差异。
我们的研究结果表明,衰老的嗓音可能并非普遍以呼吸声特质为特征,这暗示了需要对嗓音质量的种族多样性进行进一步研究。