Wang Wei, Wang Chen, Dawson D Brian, Thorland Erik C, Lundquist Patrick A, Eckloff Bruce W, Wu Yanhong, Baheti Saurabh, Evans Jared M, Scherer Steven S, Dyck Peter J, Klein Christopher J
From the Departments of Neurology, Peripheral Nerve Division (W.W., P.J.D., C.J.K.), Department of Health Science Research (C.W., S.B., J.M.E.), Laboratory Medicine and Pathology (D.B.D., E.C.T., P.A.L., Y.W., C.J.K.), Medical Genome Facility (B.W.E., Y.W.), and Medical Genetics (C.J.K., D.B.D.), Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN; Department of Neurology (W.W.), China-Japan Friendship Hospital, Beijing, China; and Department of Neurology (S.S.S.), Perelman School of Medicine, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia.
Neurology. 2016 May 10;86(19):1762-71. doi: 10.1212/WNL.0000000000002659. Epub 2016 Apr 13.
To assess the efficiency of target-enrichment next-generation sequencing (NGS) with copy number assessment in inherited neuropathy diagnosis.
A 197 polyneuropathy gene panel was designed to assess for mutations in 93 patients with inherited or idiopathic neuropathy without known genetic cause. We applied our novel copy number variation algorithm on NGS data, and validated the identified copy number mutations using CytoScan (Affymetrix). Cost and efficacy of this targeted NGS approach was compared to earlier evaluations.
Average coverage depth was ∼760× (median = 600, 99.4% > 100×). Among 93 patients, 18 mutations were identified in 17 cases (18%), including 3 copy number mutations: 2 PMP22 duplications and 1 MPZ duplication. The 2 patients with PMP22 duplication presented with bulbar and respiratory involvement and had absent extremity nerve conductions, leading to axonal diagnosis. Average onset age of these 17 patients was 25 years (2-61 years), vs 45 years for those without genetic discovery. Among those with onset age less than 40 years, the diagnostic yield of targeted NGS approach is high (27%) and cost savings is significant (∼20%). However, the cost savings for patients with late onset age and without family history is not demonstrated.
Incorporating copy number analysis in target-enrichment NGS approach improved the efficiency of mutation discovery for chronic, inherited, progressive length-dependent polyneuropathy diagnosis. The new technology is facilitating a simplified genetic diagnostic algorithm utilizing targeted NGS, clinical phenotypes, age at onset, and family history to improve diagnosis efficiency. Our findings prompt a need for updating the current practice parameters and payer guidelines.
评估靶向富集二代测序(NGS)结合拷贝数评估在遗传性神经病诊断中的效率。
设计了一个包含197个多神经病基因的检测板,用于评估93例病因不明的遗传性或特发性神经病患者的突变情况。我们将新型拷贝数变异算法应用于NGS数据,并使用CytoScan(Affymetrix)验证所识别的拷贝数突变。将这种靶向NGS方法的成本和效率与早期评估进行比较。
平均覆盖深度约为760倍(中位数 = 600,99.4% > 100倍)。在93例患者中,17例(18%)鉴定出18个突变,包括3个拷贝数突变:2个PMP22重复和1个MPZ重复。2例PMP22重复患者出现延髓和呼吸受累,肢体神经传导消失,导致轴索性诊断。这17例患者的平均发病年龄为25岁(2 - 61岁),而未发现基因异常的患者为45岁。在发病年龄小于40岁的患者中,靶向NGS方法的诊断率较高(27%),成本节约显著(约20%)。然而,对于发病年龄较晚且无家族史的患者,未显示出成本节约。
在靶向富集NGS方法中纳入拷贝数分析提高了慢性、遗传性、进行性长度依赖性多神经病诊断中突变发现的效率。新技术正在促进一种简化的基因诊断算法,利用靶向NGS、临床表型、发病年龄和家族史来提高诊断效率。我们的研究结果提示需要更新当前的实践参数和支付方指南。