Özen Özgür, Kıyan Selahattin
Department of Emergency Medicine, Ege University Faculty of Medicine Hospital, İzmir-Turkey.
Ulus Travma Acil Cerrahi Derg. 2016 Mar;22(2):175-83. doi: 10.5505/tjtes.2015.06706.
Use of narcotic analgesics in patients with acute abdominal pain does not cause delayed misdiagnosis, increases patient comfort and does not suppresses physical examination. The purpose of this study was to determine attitudes anddaily practices of emergency medicine (EM) specialists, residents and faculty members in Turkey on the use of analgesics in patients with acute abdominal pain and factors affecting their decisions on the use of analgesics.
A cross-sectional study was performed between November 15, 2013 and January 25, 2014 by conducting a questionnaire to EM physicians working in University Hospitals, Education and Research Hospitals of the Ministry of Health, State Hospitals, and Private Hospitals in Turkey.
A total of 803 questionnaires (participation rate: 47%) were completed. 59.3% (n=470) of the participants were research assistants. 49.5% of the participants reported that analgesic drugs "suppressed'' physical examination findings. They stated that 90% of the patients "always'' and "often'' requested analgesics and that 34.6% of surgery consultant physicians "rarely" recommended the use of analgesics, while 28.7% "never" recommended, and that there was no common policy established together with surgical departments (79.1%). According to the comparison between the EM specialists and residents, residents in the group stating that they would "never'' use analgesics were higher than specialists in number (p=0.002); residents reported that they administered analgesics "upon surgical intervention decision", while specialists reported that they administered analgesics "after patient's examination and treatment plan" (p=0.021); residents reported that analgesics "suppressed'' physical examination findings, while specialists reported that analgesics "clarified'' physical examination findings (p<0.0001); residents reported that they did not administer analgesics "before examination by surgeon'', while specialists reported otherwise (p=0.0001). Senior residents (>24 months) reported that they administered analgesics "often'' compared to junior residents (p=0.034) and that junior residents believed that the use of analgesics would "suppress physical examination findings'' at a higher percentage (p=0.002).
The rates of use of analgesics in patients with acute abdominal pain by EM physicians are very low. The rates of use of analgesics by EM residents are much lower compared to EM specialists, and they highly believe that analgesic drugs suppress physical examination findings. Residents tend to administer analgesic drugs at a later stage. As seniority of residents increases, the rate of analgesics use and the opinion that analgesic drugs have no effect on physical examination findings increases.
在急性腹痛患者中使用麻醉性镇痛药不会导致误诊延迟,可提高患者舒适度且不会影响体格检查。本研究的目的是确定土耳其急诊医学(EM)专科医生、住院医师和教职员工对急性腹痛患者使用镇痛药的态度和日常做法,以及影响他们使用镇痛药决策的因素。
2013年11月15日至2014年1月25日期间,对在土耳其大学医院、卫生部教育与研究医院、国立医院和私立医院工作的急诊医生进行问卷调查,开展了一项横断面研究。
共完成803份问卷(参与率:47%)。59.3%(n = 470)的参与者为研究助理。49.5%的参与者报告称镇痛药“影响”了体格检查结果。他们表示90%的患者“总是”和“经常”要求使用镇痛药,34.6%的外科会诊医生“很少”推荐使用镇痛药,28.7%“从不”推荐,且与外科科室未共同制定通用政策(79.1%)。根据急诊专科医生和住院医师的比较,表示“从不”使用镇痛药的住院医师人数多于专科医生(p = 0.002);住院医师报告他们在“做出手术干预决定后”给予镇痛药,而专科医生报告他们在“患者检查和制定治疗方案后”给予镇痛药(p = 0.021);住院医师报告镇痛药“影响”了体格检查结果,而专科医生报告镇痛药“有助于明确”体格检查结果(p < 0.0001);住院医师报告他们不在“外科医生检查前”给予镇痛药,而专科医生则相反(p = 0.0001)。与低年资住院医师相比,高年资住院医师(> 24个月)报告他们“经常”给予镇痛药(p = 0.034),且低年资住院医师认为使用镇痛药会“影响体格检查结果”的比例更高(p = 0.002)。
急诊医生对急性腹痛患者使用镇痛药的比例非常低。与急诊专科医生相比,急诊住院医师使用镇痛药的比例要低得多,且他们坚信镇痛药会影响体格检查结果。住院医师倾向于在较晚阶段给予镇痛药。随着住院医师年资的增加,镇痛药的使用比例以及镇痛药对体格检查结果无影响的观点也会增加。