Büyükcam Ayşe, Kara Ateş, Bedir Tuğba, Gülhan Belgin, Özdemir Halil, Sütçü Murat, Düzgöl Mine, Arslan Aslı, Tekin Tuna, Çelebi Solmaz, Kukul Musa Gürel, Bayhan Gülsüm İclal, Köşker Muhammet, Karbuz Adem, Çelik Melda, Kocabay Sütçü Zümrüt, Metin Özge, Karakaşlılar Sebahat, Dağlı Abdullah, Kara Soner Sertan, Albayrak Eda, Kanık Saliha, Tezer Hasan, Parlakay Aslınur, Çiftci Ergin, Somer Ayper, Devrim İlker, Kurugöl Zafer, Dinleyici Ener Çağrı, Atla Pınar
Hacettepe University, Pediatric Infection Department, Ankara, Turkey.
Hacettepe University, Pediatric Infection Department, Ankara, Turkey.
Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol. 2018 Apr;107:14-20. doi: 10.1016/j.ijporl.2018.01.011. Epub 2018 Jan 31.
Acute otitis media (AOM) is predominantly a disease of childhood and one of the common reasons for prescribing antibiotics. Ear pain is the main symptom of AOM, with the result that parents frequently seek immediate medical assistance for their children. Antibiotic therapy for AOM does not provide symptomatic relief in the first 24 hours, and analgesics are commonly recommended for relieving the pain associated with AOM. The aims of the present study were to assess pediatricians' attitudes toward AOM and ear pain management in Turkey.
This multicenter descriptive questionnaire study was conducted in 20 centers from different geographic locations in Turkey, with 977 pediatricians, between June 2015 and December 2016. The questionnaire comprised 20 questions focusing on the pediatricians' sociodemographic variables, experiences, and treatment related to AOM and ear pain.
Of the pediatricians, 58.2% were residents, 36.5% were specialists, and 4.3% were lecturers. Most participants were working in a university hospital (54.8%) or education and research hospital (32.2%). In general daily practice, the AOM diagnosis rates were between 6% and 20% in outpatient clinics, and 52.3% of the participants stated the patients complained about ear pain in pediatric clinics. The watchful waiting (WW) rate, as opposed to immediate antibiotic treatment, was 39.8% for all the pediatricians. The pediatric residents used the WW strategy less than the specialists and lecturers did (p = 0.004). The rates of the WW strategy were higher in outpatient clinics where AOM was commonly diagnosed (p < 0.001). The most common antibiotic prescribed for AOM was amoxicillin clavulanate (76.7%). The mean recommended treatment period for AOM was 9.3 ± 2.2 days. The choices for systemic ear pain treatment were acetaminophen (26.8%), ibuprofen (29.4%), and alternating between ibuprofen and acetaminophen (43.9%). Moreover, 34.6% of the participants recommended topical agents for otalgia. Topical agents were more commonly recommended by the pediatric residents than specialists or lecturers (p < 0.001). Finally, 58.3% of pediatricians had experiences of the parents' usage of a variety of herbal and folk remedies, such as breast milk or olive oil, for their children's ear pain.
Amoxicillin clavulanate was the most frequently prescribed antibiotic for AOM. WW was approved by the pediatricians, and having more AOM patients was a significant factor in the physicians' choice of WW; nevertheless, the WW rate was poor. Implementation of educational intervention strategies will help pediatricians in improving their compliance with evidence-based guidelines for AOM treatment. Otalgia is taken seriously by parents and pediatricians, and otalgia treatment seems to be well accepted in Turkey for providing symptomatic relief and enhancing the patients' quality of life.
急性中耳炎(AOM)主要是一种儿童疾病,也是开具抗生素的常见原因之一。耳痛是AOM的主要症状,因此家长经常会为孩子寻求即时医疗帮助。AOM的抗生素治疗在最初24小时内无法缓解症状,通常建议使用镇痛药来缓解与AOM相关的疼痛。本研究的目的是评估土耳其儿科医生对AOM及耳痛管理的态度。
这项多中心描述性问卷调查研究于2015年6月至2016年12月在土耳其不同地理位置的20个中心对977名儿科医生开展。问卷包含20个问题,聚焦于儿科医生的社会人口统计学变量、经验以及与AOM和耳痛相关的治疗。
儿科医生中,58.2%是住院医师,36.5%是专科医生,4.3%是讲师。大多数参与者在大学医院(54.8%)或教学与研究医院(32.2%)工作。在一般日常实践中,门诊诊所的AOM诊断率在6%至20%之间,52.3%的参与者表示儿科诊所的患者抱怨耳痛。与立即使用抗生素治疗相反,所有儿科医生的观察等待(WW)率为39.8%。儿科住院医师使用WW策略的比例低于专科医生和讲师(p = 0.004)。在AOM常见诊断的门诊诊所,WW策略的比例更高(p < 0.001)。AOM最常用的抗生素是阿莫西林克拉维酸(76.7%)。AOM的平均推荐治疗期为9.3±2.2天。全身性耳痛治疗的选择是对乙酰氨基酚(26.8%)、布洛芬(29.4%)以及布洛芬和对乙酰氨基酚交替使用(43.9%)。此外,34.6%的参与者推荐局部用药治疗耳痛。儿科住院医师比专科医生或讲师更常推荐局部用药(p < 0.001)。最后,58.3%的儿科医生有过家长使用各种草药和民间疗法(如母乳或橄榄油)治疗孩子耳痛的经历。
阿莫西林克拉维酸是AOM最常开具的抗生素。WW得到了儿科医生的认可,AOM患者较多是医生选择WW的一个重要因素;然而,WW率较低。实施教育干预策略将有助于儿科医生提高对AOM治疗循证指南的依从性。耳痛受到家长和儿科医生的重视,耳痛治疗在土耳其似乎被广泛接受,以缓解症状并提高患者生活质量。