Posener J A, LaHaye A, Cheifetz P N
Massachusetts Mental Health Center, Boston 02115.
Can J Psychiatry. 1989 Apr;34(3):171-6. doi: 10.1177/070674378903400302.
Suicide rates for adolescents have shown a substantial increase over the past 30 years, but there is little information regarding the clinical status of adolescents who end their lives. In the adult literature, one avenue to understanding the psychologic condition immediately prior to the self-destructive act has been the study of suicide notes, and the present study constitutes the first systematic investigation of notes left by children or adolescents. Records of death were examined in the Office of the Coroner, City of Montreal, and all suicides between ages 10 and 20 were identified for the years 1978 to 1982. Seventeen individuals who left notes were identified, comprising 10% of the population of suicides. Suicides who left notes did not differ from the total group in age and sex distribution but were more likely to choose shooting as a method. The content of the notes was studied in terms of 11 variables which had proven characteristic of suicide notes in the adult literature, and the results were compared to those reported for adults. In general, our results support a psychoanalytic perspective which understands suicide as resulting from an ambivalent attachment to an object, loss of the object, internalization, and the direction of aggression against the self. Cases appeared to fall into two clusters. Older adolescents were more concrete, left specific instructions, did not address the note, did not give a reason for the act, and tended to choose intoxication as a method.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
在过去30年里,青少年自杀率大幅上升,但关于结束自己生命的青少年的临床状况,几乎没有相关信息。在成人文献中,了解自杀行为发生前心理状况的一个途径是研究自杀遗书,而本研究是对儿童或青少年留下的遗书进行的首次系统调查。我们查阅了蒙特利尔市验尸官办公室的死亡记录,确定了1978年至1982年间所有10至20岁的自杀者。我们找出了17名留下遗书的自杀者,占自杀总人数的10%。留下遗书的自杀者在年龄和性别分布上与总群体没有差异,但更倾向于选择枪击作为自杀方式。我们根据成人文献中已证实的11个自杀遗书特征变量来研究遗书内容,并将结果与成人的报告结果进行比较。总体而言,我们的结果支持精神分析观点,即认为自杀是由对某一客体的矛盾情感依恋、客体丧失、内化以及将攻击指向自身所导致的。案例似乎分为两类。年龄较大的青少年表述更具体,留下了具体指示,未称呼收信人,未说明自杀原因,且倾向于选择中毒作为自杀方式。(摘要截选至250词)