Pei Xinhong, Mo Yueqiang, Huang Peng
Department of Orthopaedics Surgery, Children's Hospital of Fudan University, Wanyuan 399, Minhang District, Shanghai, China, 201102.
Int Orthop. 2016 Nov;40(11):2417-2422. doi: 10.1007/s00264-016-3206-3. Epub 2016 May 26.
Although the most complex management of Gartland type IV supracondylar humeral fracture (SCHF) due to instability, the gold standard of initial treatment remains closed reduction and percutaneous pinning. However, open reduction was inevitable in most published studies. This study reports the outcome of treatment by leverage-assisted closed reduction.
Twenty-seven patients were diagnosed as Gartland type IV SCHF during surgery in 214 preoperative Gartland type III fractures. Leverage-assisted reduction with percutaneous lateral pinning was done in these patients after failure of close reduction. Evaluations were performed with radiographic examination, clinical assessment and Flynn's criteria by interview and physical examination.
All 27 patients obtained acceptable reduction by leverage-assisted close reduction and percutaneous pinning. The average follow-up was 23.6 (18-30 months). There was no neurovascular complication, infection, nonunion, myositis ossificans or Volkmann's contracture. Evaluation of Baumann's angle was towards varus (74-74.2°). There was no significant difference (p = 0.1876). Flynn's criteria were excellent in 22 (81.5 %) patients, good in four (14.8 %) and fair in one (3.7 %). The rate of excellent and good outcome was 96.3 % and of satisfactory 100 %.
We recommend leverage-assisted closed reduction as an option before open reduction in type IV SCHF, not only for gold standard management but also because of satisfactory outcomes and the low incidence of major complications.
尽管由于不稳定,肱骨髁上骨折(SCHF)的加特兰IV型是最复杂的骨折类型,但初始治疗的金标准仍然是闭合复位和经皮穿针固定。然而,在大多数已发表的研究中,切开复位是不可避免的。本研究报告了杠杆辅助闭合复位的治疗结果。
在214例术前加特兰III型骨折患者中,有27例在手术中被诊断为加特兰IV型SCHF。在闭合复位失败后,对这些患者进行了杠杆辅助复位及经皮外侧穿针固定。通过影像学检查、临床评估以及采用弗林标准进行访谈和体格检查来进行评估。
所有27例患者均通过杠杆辅助闭合复位和经皮穿针固定获得了可接受的复位效果。平均随访时间为23.6(18 - 30个月)。未出现神经血管并发症、感染、骨不连、骨化性肌炎或Volkmann挛缩。鲍曼角评估显示向内翻(74 - 74.2°),无显著差异(p = 0.1876)。弗林标准评估结果为:22例(81.5%)患者为优,4例(14.8%)为良,1例(3.7%)为可。优良率为96.3%,满意度为100%。
我们建议在IV型SCHF的切开复位之前,将杠杆辅助闭合复位作为一种选择,这不仅是因为它是金标准治疗方法,还因为其效果令人满意且主要并发症发生率低。