Tate Robyn L, Perdices Michael, Rosenkoetter Ulrike, Shadish William, Vohra Sunita, Barlow David H, Horner Robert, Kazdin Alan, Kratochwill Thomas, McDonald Skye, Sampson Margaret, Shamseer Larissa, Togher Leanne, Albin Richard, Backman Catherine, Douglas Jacinta, Evans Jonathan J, Gast David, Manolov Rumen, Mitchell Geoffrey, Nickels Lyndsey, Nikles Jane, Ownsworth Tamara, Rose Miranda, Schmid Christopher H, Wilson Barbara
Can J Occup Ther. 2016 Jun;83(3):184-95. doi: 10.1177/0008417416648124.
We developed a reporting guideline to provide authors with guidance about what should be reported when writing a paper for publication in a scientific journal using a particular type of research design: the single-case experimental design. This report describes the methods used to develop the Single-Case Reporting guideline In BEhavioural interventions (SCRIBE) 2016. As a result of 2 online surveys and a 2-day meeting of experts, the SCRIBE 2016 checklist was developed, which is a set of 26 items that authors need to address when writing about single-case research. This article complements the more detailed SCRIBE 2016 Explanation and Elaboration article (Tate et al., 2016) that provides a rationale for each of the items and examples of adequate reporting from the literature. Both these resources will assist authors to prepare reports of single-case research with clarity, completeness, accuracy, and transparency. They will also provide journal reviewers and editors with a practical checklist against which such reports may be critically evaluated. We recommend that the SCRIBE 2016 is used by authors preparing manuscripts describing single-case research for publication, as well as journal reviewers and editors who are evaluating such manuscripts.Reporting guidelines, such as the Consolidated Standards of Reporting Trials (CONSORT) Statement, improve the reporting of research in the medical literature (Turner et al., 2012). Many such guidelines exist and the CONSORT Extension to Nonpharmacological Trials (Boutron et al., 2008) provides suitable guidance for reporting between-groups intervention studies in the behavioral sciences. The CONSORT Extension for N-of-1 Trials (CENT 2015) was developed for multiple crossover trials with single individuals in the medical sciences (Shamseer et al., 2015; Vohra et al., 2015), but there is no reporting guideline in the CONSORT tradition for single-case research used in the behavioral sciences. We developed the Single-Case Reporting guideline In BEhavioural interventions (SCRIBE) 2016 to meet this need. This Statement article describes the methodology of the development of the SCRIBE 2016, along with the outcome of 2 Delphi surveys and a consensus meeting of experts. We present the resulting 26-item SCRIBE 2016 checklist. The article complements the more detailed SCRIBE 2016 Explanation and Elaboration article (Tate et al., 2016) that provides a rationale for each of the items and examples of adequate reporting from the literature. Both these resources will assist authors to prepare reports of single-case research with clarity, completeness, accuracy, and transparency. They will also provide journal reviewers and editors with a practical checklist against which such reports may be critically evaluated.
我们制定了一份报告指南,为作者提供指导,说明在使用特定类型的研究设计(即单病例实验设计)撰写论文以供在科学期刊上发表时应报告哪些内容。本报告描述了用于制定《2016年行为干预单病例报告指南》(SCRIBE)的方法。经过两次在线调查和为期两天的专家会议,制定了SCRIBE 2016清单,这是作者在撰写单病例研究时需要涵盖的一组26项内容。本文补充了更详细的《SCRIBE 2016解释与阐述》文章(泰特等人,2016年),该文章为每项内容提供了理论依据以及文献中充分报告的示例。这两种资源都将帮助作者清晰、完整、准确和透明地撰写单病例研究报告。它们还将为期刊审稿人和编辑提供一份实用清单,据此可对这类报告进行严格评估。我们建议准备描述单病例研究以供发表的手稿的作者,以及评估此类手稿的期刊审稿人和编辑使用SCRIBE 2016。报告指南,如《报告试验的统一标准》(CONSORT)声明,改善了医学文献中研究的报告情况(特纳等人,2012年)。存在许多这样的指南,《非药物试验的CONSORT扩展》(布特龙等人,2008年)为行为科学中的组间干预研究报告提供了合适的指导。《单病例试验的CONSORT扩展》(CENT 2015)是为医学科学中针对个体的多个交叉试验而制定的(沙姆西尔等人,2015年;沃拉等人,2015年),但在CONSORT传统中没有针对行为科学中使用的单病例研究的报告指南。我们制定了《2016年行为干预单病例报告指南》(SCRIBE)以满足这一需求。本声明文章描述了SCRIBE 2016的制定方法,以及两次德尔菲调查和一次专家共识会议的结果。我们展示了由此产生的26项SCRIBE 2016清单。本文补充了更详细的《SCRIBE 2016解释与阐述》文章(泰特等人,2016年),该文章为每项内容提供了理论依据以及文献中充分报告的示例。这两种资源都将帮助作者清晰、完整、准确和透明地撰写单病例研究报告。它们还将为期刊审稿人和编辑提供一份实用清单,据此可对这类报告进行严格评估。