Bischoff Alexander
Division of Tropical and Humanitarian Medicine, University Hospitals of Geneva, Geneva, Switzerland.
School of Health Sciences, University of Applied Sciences and Arts Western Switzerland, Fribourg, Switzerland;
Glob Health Action. 2016 May 27;9:29404. doi: 10.3402/gha.v9.29404. eCollection 2016.
In 2007, the Tanzanian government called for improvements in its primary health care services. Part of this initiative was to accelerate the training rate for nurses qualified to work in rural areas. The aim of this study was to reflect on the issues experienced whilst establishing and implementing a faith-based organisation (FBO) nursing school and make recommendations for other similar initiatives.
This paper describes an auto-ethnographic case study design to identify the key difficulties involved with establishing and implementing a new nursing school, and which factors helped the project achieve its goals.
Six themes emerged from the experiences that shaped the course of the project: 1) Motivation can be sustained if the rationale of the project is in line with its aims. Indeed, the project's primary health care focus was to strengthen the nursing workforce and build a public-private partnership with an FBO. All these were strengths, which helped in the midst of all the uncertainties. 2) Communication was an important and often underrated factor for all types of development projects. 3) Managing the unknown and 4) managing expectations characterised the project inception. Almost all themes had to do with 5) handling conflicts. With so many participants having their own agendas, tensions were unavoidable. A final theme was 6) the need to adjust to ever-changing targets.
This retrospective auto-ethnographic manuscript serves as a small-scale case study, to illustrate how issues that can be generalised to other settings can be deconstructed to demonstrate how they influence health development projects in developing countries. From this narrative of experiences, key recommendations include the following: 1) Find the right ratio of stakeholders, participants, and agendas, and do not overload the project; 2) Be alert and communicate as much as possible with staff and do not ignore issues hoping they will solve themselves; 3) Think flexibly and do not stubbornly stick to original plans that might not be working; 4) Be realistic and do not romanticise. Embarking on such a project was a timely response to the Tanzanian's government call for strengthening Primary Health Care and for rapidly accelerating the training of nurses able to work in rural areas.
2007年,坦桑尼亚政府呼吁改善其初级卫生保健服务。该倡议的一部分是加快培训有资格在农村地区工作的护士的速度。本研究的目的是反思在建立和实施一所基于信仰的组织(FBO)护理学校过程中遇到的问题,并为其他类似倡议提出建议。
本文描述了一种自我民族志案例研究设计,以确定建立和实施一所新护理学校所涉及的关键困难,以及哪些因素有助于该项目实现其目标。
从塑造项目进程的经历中出现了六个主题:1)如果项目的基本原理与其目标一致,动力就能持续。事实上,该项目对初级卫生保健的关注重点是加强护理人员队伍,并与一个基于信仰的组织建立公私伙伴关系。所有这些都是优势,在所有的不确定性中起到了帮助作用。2)沟通对于所有类型的发展项目来说都是一个重要且常常被低估的因素。3)应对未知情况和4)管理期望是项目启动阶段的特点。几乎所有主题都与5)处理冲突有关。由于众多参与者都有自己的议程,紧张关系不可避免。最后一个主题是6)需要适应不断变化的目标。
这份回顾性的自我民族志手稿作为一个小规模案例研究,来说明那些可推广到其他环境的问题是如何被解构,以展示它们如何影响发展中国家的卫生发展项目的。从这段经历的叙述中,关键建议如下:1)找到利益相关者、参与者和议程的正确比例,不要使项目负担过重;2)保持警觉,尽可能与工作人员沟通,不要忽视问题,指望它们会自行解决;3)灵活思考,不要固执地坚持可能行不通的原计划;4)实事求是,不要理想化。开展这样一个项目是对坦桑尼亚政府加强初级卫生保健以及迅速加快培训能在农村地区工作的护士的呼吁的及时回应。