Garcia Patrícia Petromilli Nordi Sasso, Presoto Cristina Dupim, Maroco João, Campos Juliana Alvares Duarte Bonini
Araraquara Dental School - UNESP, Univ Estadual Paulista.
Med Lav. 2016 May 26;107(3):235-42.
Dentists are exposed to occupational hazards, such as musculoskeletal disorders, in which symptoms can manifest early in clinical practice.
To estimate the reliability and validity of the Portuguese version of the "Questionnaire on work-related activities that may contribute to musculoskeletal symptoms" when applied to dental students.
553 Brazilian students participated in the study. The one-factor structure originally proposed was tested through confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) using the indexes c2/df, CFI, GFI, and RMSEA. After observing an inadequate good fit (c2/df=7.140, CFI=0.791, GFI=0.778, RMSEA=0.129), the sample was subdivided into 3 groups and an exploratory factor analysis was conducted (EFA) (n=255). A CFA was then conducted using a subsample (n=113). To test the invariance of the obtained factorial solution, a multi-group analysis was performed using a third sample, independent from the others (n=185). The convergent (AVE) and discriminant (r2) validity were assessed. The composite reliability (CR), Cronbach's alpha coefficient (a), and intra-class correlation coefficient (r) were calculated.
In the EFA, 3 factors were extracted: "Repetitiveness," "Working posture," and "External factors" (c2=21895.154; p<0.001; KMO=0.905; l1=6.683; l2=1.464; l3=1.277) that explained 62.82% of the total variance. The three-factor model presented an adequate good fit (n=113 and n=185) (c2/df=2.259; CFI=0.885; GFI=0.833; RMSEA=0.066). The convergent validity was compromised only for "Repetitiveness" (AVE=0.412-0.653). The discriminant validity (r2=0.333-0.428), composite reliability, internal consistency, and reproducibility were adequate for all factors (CR=0.736-0.883; a=0.747-0.876; r=0.729-0.940).
The questionnaire proved to be reliable and valid for the sample of dentistry students if the three-factor model is used.
牙医面临职业危害,如肌肉骨骼疾病,其症状可能在临床实践早期就会出现。
评估应用于牙科学生的葡萄牙语版“可能导致肌肉骨骼症状的工作相关活动问卷”的信度和效度。
553名巴西学生参与了该研究。最初提出的单因素结构通过验证性因素分析(CFA)进行测试,使用的指标有c2/df、CFI、GFI和RMSEA。在观察到拟合度不佳(c2/df = 7.140,CFI = 0.791,GFI = 0.778,RMSEA = 0.129)后,将样本分为3组并进行探索性因素分析(EFA)(n = 255)。然后使用一个子样本(n = 113)进行CFA。为了测试获得的因子解的不变性,使用与其他样本独立的第三个样本(n = 185)进行多组分析。评估收敛效度(AVE)和区分效度(r2)。计算组合信度(CR)、克朗巴哈α系数(a)和组内相关系数(r)。
在EFA中,提取了3个因子:“重复性”、“工作姿势”和“外部因素”(c2 = 21895.154;p < 0.001;KMO = 0.905;l1 = 6.683;l2 = 1.464;l3 = 1.277),它们解释了总方差的62.82%。三因素模型呈现出良好的拟合度(n = 113和n = 185)(c2/df = 2.259;CFI = 0.885;GFI = 0.833;RMSEA = 0.066)。仅“重复性”的收敛效度受到影响(AVE = 0.412 - 0.653)。所有因子的区分效度(r2 = 0.333 - 0.428)、组合信度、内部一致性和可重复性都足够(CR = 0.736 - 0.883;a = 0.747 - 0.876;r = 0.729 - 0.940)。
如果使用三因素模型,该问卷对牙科学生样本被证明是可靠且有效的。