Aryeetey Genevieve Cecilia, Nonvignon Justice, Amissah Caroline, Buckle Gilbert, Aikins Moses
University of Ghana, College of Health Science, School of Public Health, P. O. Box LG 13, Legon, Ghana.
Christian Health Association of Ghana (CHAG), 21 Jubilee Street, Labone, P. O. Box AN 7316, Accra, Ghana.
Global Health. 2016 Jun 7;12(1):32. doi: 10.1186/s12992-016-0171-y.
In 2004, Ghana began implementation of a National Health Insurance Scheme (NHIS) to minimize out-of-pocket expenditure at the point of use of service. The implementation of the scheme was accompanied by increased access and use of health care services. Evidence suggests most health facilities are faced with management challenges in the delivery of services. The study aimed to assess the effect of the introduction of the NHIS on health service delivery in mission health facilities in Ghana. We conceptualised the effect of NHIS on facilities using service delivery indicators such as outpatient and inpatient turn out, estimation of general service readiness, revenue and expenditure, claims processing and availability of essential medicines. We collected data from 38 mission facilities, grouped into the three ecological zones; southern, middle and northern. Structured questionnaires and exit interviews were used to collect data for the periods 2003 and 2010. The data was analysed in SPSS and MS Excel.
The facilities displayed high readiness to deliver services. There were significant increases in outpatient and inpatient attendance, revenue, expenditure and improved access to medicines. Generally, facilities reported increased readiness to deliver services. However, challenging issues around high rates of non-reimbursement of NHIS claims due to errors in claims processing, lack of feedback regarding errors, and lack of clarity on claims reporting procedures were reported.
The implementation of the NHIS saw improvement and expansion of services resulting in benefits to the facilities as well as constraints. The constraints could be minimized if claims processing is improved at the facility level and delays in reimbursements also reduced.
2004年,加纳开始实施国家健康保险计划(NHIS),以尽量减少在使用服务时的自付费用。该计划的实施伴随着医疗服务可及性和使用率的提高。有证据表明,大多数医疗机构在提供服务方面面临管理挑战。该研究旨在评估引入NHIS对加纳教会医疗机构医疗服务提供的影响。我们使用诸如门诊和住院人数、总体服务准备情况评估、收入与支出、理赔处理以及基本药物供应等服务提供指标来概念化NHIS对医疗机构的影响。我们从38个教会医疗机构收集了数据,这些机构分为三个生态区域:南部、中部和北部。使用结构化问卷和出院访谈收集2003年和2010年期间的数据。数据在SPSS和MS Excel中进行分析。
这些医疗机构表现出很高的服务准备度。门诊和住院就诊人数、收入、支出均显著增加,药品可及性也有所改善。总体而言,医疗机构报告称服务准备度有所提高。然而,也报告了一些具有挑战性的问题,比如由于理赔处理错误导致NHIS理赔未报销率高、缺乏关于错误的反馈以及理赔报告程序不明确。
NHIS的实施带来了服务的改善和扩展,给医疗机构带来了好处,但也存在一些限制。如果在机构层面改善理赔处理并减少报销延迟,这些限制可以降至最低。