Adetunji O A, Adigun N F, Odeniyi M A
Afr J Med Med Sci. 2015 Sep;44(3):269-76.
This study was undertaken with the objective of evaluating the pharmaceutical and chemical equivalence of some commercially available loratadine tablets, and offers a possible explanation for the therapeutic failure of the drug products.
The equivalence of eight brands of loratadine hydrochloride tablets labelled A to H was assessed and compared with the Innovator brand labelled I. Visual observation and uniformity of weight tests were carried out on the tablets, mechanical properties were assessed using friability and crushing strength tests as parameters. Release properties of the tablets were assessed by disintegration and dissolution tests. Assay was based on non-aqueous titration procedure using crystal violet solution indicator.
All the brands studied were white in colour with different shapes and lustre, and complied with the official specification for uniformity of tablet weight. Friability tests showed that only brand G lost more than 1% of its initial weight, while brands A and E failed the crushing strength test. Brand C did not undergo complete disintegration within 15 minutes, while brands A, B, F and G had less than 70% of the active drug content still in solution after 45 minutes. Two of the brands had active drug content between officially specified range of 98.5% and 101.5% for loratadine tablets.
There was a large variation in the pharmaceutical properties of the commercially available loratadine hydrochloride tablets that were selected for this study. Six of the brands evaluated exhibited poor pharmaceutical properties. Generally, only two of the brands were pharmaceutically equivalent with the innovator brand.
本研究旨在评估一些市售氯雷他定片的药学和化学等效性,并为药品治疗失败提供可能的解释。
评估了八个品牌的氯雷他定片(标记为A至H)的等效性,并与标记为I的创新品牌进行比较。对片剂进行外观观察和重量均匀度测试,以脆碎度和抗压强度测试为参数评估机械性能。通过崩解和溶出度测试评估片剂的释放特性。含量测定基于使用结晶紫溶液指示剂的非水滴定法。
所有研究的品牌片剂均为白色,形状和光泽各异,且符合片剂重量均匀度的官方规格。脆碎度测试表明,只有品牌G的重量损失超过其初始重量的1%,而品牌A和E的抗压强度测试不合格。品牌C在15分钟内未完全崩解,而品牌A、B、F和G在45分钟后仍有不到70%的活性药物成分溶解在溶液中。其中两个品牌的氯雷他定片活性药物含量在官方规定的98.5%至101.5%范围内。
本研究中选择的市售氯雷他定片的药学性质存在很大差异。评估的八个品牌中有六个表现出较差的药学性质。总体而言,只有两个品牌与创新品牌在药学上等效。