Ried L D, McKenna D A, Horn J R
Department of Pharmacy Practice, School of Pharmacy, University of Washington, Seattle 98195.
Ther Drug Monit. 1989;11(3):253-63. doi: 10.1097/00007691-198905000-00007.
In order to quantify the impact of therapeutic drug monitoring (TDM) services on the average number of serum drug assays (SDAs) ordered for patients, a meta-analysis was conducted on the data collected from 16 published and unpublished studies. Overall, TDM has no effect on the number of SDAs ordered per patient. However, there were a number of moderator variables that influenced the results. In studies utilizing control groups for comparison, TDM service-monitored patients were ordered fewer SDAs than nonmonitored patients. When data from the same institution were collected before and after implementation of a TDM service, there was an increase in the number of SDAs per patient. Aminoglycoside patients monitored by a TDM service were ordered more SDAs and nonaminoglycoside monitored patients were ordered fewer SDAs than nonmonitored patients. When the pharmacy department determined when the SDAs were to be collected and adjusted the dose, monitored patients were ordered fewer SDAs than nonmonitored patients. However, when the pharmacy department did not have control of these parameters, the TDM patients were ordered more SDAs than nonmonitored patients. Methodologic limitations of the studies and their possible effects on the results are discussed.
为了量化治疗药物监测(TDM)服务对患者血清药物检测(SDA)平均检测次数的影响,对从16项已发表和未发表的研究中收集的数据进行了荟萃分析。总体而言,TDM对每位患者的SDA检测次数没有影响。然而,有许多调节变量影响了结果。在利用对照组进行比较的研究中,接受TDM服务监测的患者的SDA检测次数比未监测的患者少。当在实施TDM服务之前和之后收集同一机构的数据时,每位患者的SDA检测次数有所增加。接受TDM服务监测的氨基糖苷类药物患者的SDA检测次数比未监测的患者多,而接受TDM服务监测的非氨基糖苷类药物患者的SDA检测次数比未监测的患者少。当药房部门确定何时采集SDA并调整剂量时,接受监测的患者的SDA检测次数比未监测的患者少。然而,当药房部门无法控制这些参数时,接受TDM服务监测的患者的SDA检测次数比未监测的患者多。讨论了研究的方法学局限性及其对结果可能产生的影响。