Kolahi J, Khazaei S
Dental Hypotheses, Isfahan, Iran.
Torabinejad Dental Research Centre, School of Dentistry, Isfahan University of Medical Sciences, Isfahan, Iran.
Br Dent J. 2016 Jun 10;220(11):569-74. doi: 10.1038/sj.bdj.2016.411.
Introduction Altmetrics is a new and emerging scholarly tool that measures online attention surrounding journal articles. Altmetric data resources include: policy documents, news outlets, blogs, online reference managers (eg Mendeley and CiteULike), post-publication peer-review forums (eg PubPeer and Publons), social media (eg Twitter, Facebook, Weibo, Google(+), Pinterest, Reddit), Wikipedia, sites running Stack Exchange (Q&A), and reviews on F1000 and YouTube.Methods To identify the top 50 dental articles in 2014, PubMed was searched using the following query "("2014/1/1"[PDAT]:"2014/12/31"[PDAT]) and jsubsetd[text]" in December, 2015. Consequently, all PubMed records were extracted and sent to Altmetric LLP (London, UK) as a CSV file for examination. Data were analysed by Microsoft Office Excel 2010 using descriptive statistics and charts.Results Using PubMed searches,15,132 dental articles were found in 2014. The mean Altmetric score of 50 top dental articles in 2014 was 69.5 ± 73.3 (95% CI: -74.14 to 213.14). The British Dental Journal (48%) and Journal of Dental Research (16%) had the maximum number of top articles. Twitter (67.13%), Mendeley (15.89%) and news outlets (10.92%) were the most popular altmetric data resources.Discussion Altmetrics are intended to supplement bibliometrics, not replace them. Altmetrics is a fresh and emerging arena for the dental research community. We believe that dental clinical practitioners, research scientists, research directors and journal editors must pay more attention to altmetrics as a new and rapid tool to measure the social impact of scholarly articles.
引言
替代计量学是一种新兴的学术工具,用于衡量围绕期刊文章的在线关注度。替代计量学的数据资源包括:政策文件、新闻媒体、博客、在线参考文献管理器(如Mendeley和CiteULike)、出版后同行评审论坛(如PubPeer和Publons)、社交媒体(如Twitter、Facebook、微博、谷歌+、Pinterest、Reddit)、维基百科、运行Stack Exchange(问答)的网站,以及F1000和YouTube上的评论。
方法
为了确定2014年排名前50的牙科文章,2015年12月在PubMed中使用以下查询语句进行搜索:“(‘2014/1/1’[出版日期]:‘2014/12/31’[出版日期])且jsubsetd[文本]”。因此,所有PubMed记录都被提取出来,并作为CSV文件发送给替代计量学有限责任公司(英国伦敦)进行审查。数据使用Microsoft Office Excel 2010进行描述性统计和图表分析。
结果
通过PubMed搜索,2014年共找到15132篇牙科文章。2014年排名前50的牙科文章的替代计量学平均得分是69.5±73.3(95%置信区间:-74.14至213.14)。《英国牙科杂志》(48%)和《牙科研究杂志》(16%)拥有最多的顶级文章。Twitter(67.13%)、Mendeley(15.89%)和新闻媒体(10.92%)是最受欢迎的替代计量学数据资源。
讨论
替代计量学旨在补充文献计量学,而非取代它。替代计量学是牙科研究界一个新出现的领域。我们认为,牙科临床医生、研究科学家、研究主任和期刊编辑必须更加关注替代计量学,将其作为一种衡量学术文章社会影响力的新的快速工具。