Ventura R, Larmer S, Schenkel F S, Miller S P, Sullivan Peter
J Anim Sci. 2016 May;94(5):1844-56. doi: 10.2527/jas.2016-0322.
Genomic prediction for crossbred beef cattle has shown limited results using low- to moderate-density SNP panels. The relationship between the training and validation populations, as well as the size of the reference population, affects the prediction accuracy for genomic selection. Rotational crossbreeding systems require the usage of crossbred animals as sires and dams of future generations, so crossbred animals require accurate evaluation. Here, a novel method for grouping of purebred and crossbred animals (based exclusively on genotypes) for genomic selection was investigated. Clustering of animals to investigate the genetic similarity among different groups was performed using several genomic relationship criteria between individuals. Hierarchical clusters based on average-link criteria (computed as the mean distance between elements of each subcluster) were formed. The accuracy of genomic prediction was assessed using 1,500 bulls genotyped for 54,609 markers. Estimated breeding values based on all available phenotypic records for birth weight, weaning gain, postweaning gain, and yearling gain were calculated using BLUP methodologies and deregressed to ensure unbiased comparisons could be made across populations. A 5-fold validation technique was used to calculate direct genomic values for all genotyped bulls; the addition of unrelated animals in the reference population was also investigated. We demonstrate a decrease in genomic selection accuracy after including animals from disconnected clusters. A method to improve genomic selection for crossbred and purebred animals by clustering animals based on their genotype is suggested. Unlike traditional approaches for genomic selection with a fixed reference population, genomic prediction using clusters (GPC) chooses the best reference population for better accuracy of genomic prediction of crossbred and purebred animals using clustering methods based on genotypes. An overall average gain in accuracy of 1.30% was noted over all scenarios across all traits investigated when the GPC approach was implemented. Further investigation is required to assess this difference in accuracy when a larger genotyped population is available, especially for the comparison of groups with higher genetic dissimilarity, such as those found in industry-wide across-breed genetic evaluations.
使用低密度至中等密度的单核苷酸多态性(SNP)芯片对杂交肉牛进行基因组预测的结果有限。训练群体与验证群体之间的关系以及参考群体的大小会影响基因组选择的预测准确性。轮回杂交系统需要将杂交动物用作后代的父本和母本,因此杂交动物需要准确评估。在此,研究了一种用于基因组选择的(仅基于基因型)纯种和杂交动物分组的新方法。使用个体之间的几种基因组关系标准对动物进行聚类,以研究不同群体之间的遗传相似性。基于平均连锁标准(计算为每个子聚类中元素之间的平均距离)形成层次聚类。使用对54,609个标记进行基因分型的1500头公牛评估基因组预测的准确性。使用最佳线性无偏预测(BLUP)方法计算基于出生体重、断奶增重、断奶后增重和周岁增重的所有可用表型记录的估计育种值,并进行去回归处理,以确保能够在不同群体间进行无偏比较。采用5倍交叉验证技术计算所有基因分型公牛的直接基因组值;还研究了在参考群体中添加无关动物的情况。我们证明,纳入来自不相连聚类的动物后,基因组选择准确性会降低。建议通过基于基因型对动物进行聚类来改进杂交和纯种动物的基因组选择。与使用固定参考群体的传统基因组选择方法不同,基于聚类的基因组预测(GPC)使用基于基因型的聚类方法为杂交和纯种动物的基因组预测选择最佳参考群体,以提高准确性。当实施GPC方法时,在所研究的所有性状的所有场景中,总体平均准确性提高了1.30%。当有更大的基因分型群体时,需要进一步研究以评估这种准确性差异,特别是对于遗传差异较大的群体的比较,例如在全行业跨品种遗传评估中发现的群体。