Ghilardi P L, Casani A
Acta Otorhinolaryngol Ital. 1989 Jan-Feb;9(1):79-85.
Benign paroxysmal positional vertigo (BPPV) is quite frequently found as an otological consequence of cranial traumas; thus leading to medico-legal implications. An attempt has herewith been made to evaluate these implications on the basis of data available. Therefore, 158 patients suffering from BPPV were examined between 1984-1986. Of these 23% of the total were post-traumatic forms (of medico-legal interest). Among patients suffering from post-traumatic vestibular disturbances in the broad sense, the incidence of BPPV proved to be greater in the ages ranging from 50 to 70. In those under 30 years of age BPPV was hardly ever present (5% of the total) although when it was its origin was always post-traumatic. The temporal evolution of paroxysmal positional vertigo, which tends to spontaneously disappear, is paralleled in BPPV patients whether it is of post-traumatic origin or not. On the other hand, the subjective sensation of positional vertigo takes longer to clear up in post-traumatic BPPV patients, most likely due to factors stemming from the so-called "compensation syndrome". Any medico-legal evaluation of BPPV must, therefore, take into account its natural favorable evolution. This makes it necessary to examine the patient several times over a period of at least six months from the moment of trauma. In medico-legal terms, the features of BPPV (i.e. position setting it off, duration of vertigo, frequency with which it appears when that position is assumed, presence and duration of the positional nystagmus) lead to inability to work in from 2 to 10% of the cases.
良性阵发性位置性眩晕(BPPV)是颅脑创伤常见的耳科后果,因此引发了法医学问题。本文试图根据现有数据评估这些影响。为此,在1984年至1986年间对158例BPPV患者进行了检查。其中,23%为创伤后形式(具有法医学意义)。在广义的创伤后前庭功能障碍患者中,BPPV的发病率在50至70岁年龄段更高。在30岁以下的患者中,BPPV很少见(占总数的5%),但一旦出现,其病因总是创伤后。无论是否为创伤后起源,BPPV患者阵发性位置性眩晕的时间演变趋势都是自发消失。另一方面,创伤后BPPV患者的位置性眩晕主观感觉消失所需时间更长,这很可能是由于所谓的“代偿综合征”所致。因此,对BPPV的任何法医学评估都必须考虑其自然的良好演变。这就需要在创伤后至少六个月的时间内对患者进行多次检查。从法医学角度来看,BPPV的特征(即引发眩晕的体位、眩晕持续时间、采取该体位时眩晕出现的频率、位置性眼球震颤的存在及持续时间)导致2%至10%的患者无法工作。