Tuscan Regional Health System, Tuscany, Italy.
Meyer Children's Hospital, Florence, Italy.
JAMA Pediatr. 2016 Aug 1;170(8):e160533. doi: 10.1001/jamapediatrics.2016.0533.
Effective methods to reduce children's preoperative anxiety (such as giving information beforehand, organizing a tour of the operating room [OR] before the intervention, and incorporating clown physicians) may be difficult to implement for some hospitals, as they are time-consuming and expensive and require hospital staff to be performed.
To test the effectiveness of Clickamico, an app that shows clown physicians giving a comical and informative tour of the OR, for reducing preoperative anxiety in children.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This unblinded randomized clinical trial included 40 children aged 6 to 11 years undergoing a planned surgical intervention at a third-level Italian pediatric hospital from December 2013 to September 2014 randomized into experimental (n = 20) and control (n = 20) groups.
The experimental intervention was a 6-minute video showing 2 clown physicians visiting the OR and explaining to each other what is in the OR in a joking way. The video was shown on a tablet to children in the experimental group the afternoon preceding a planned surgical procedure. The control intervention was the standard informative intervention regarding the surgical procedure the next day.
The main outcome was preoperative anxiety. Preoperative anxiety was measured before the experimental and control interventions and immediately before entering the OR using the modified Yale Preoperative Anxiety Scale (m-YPAS).
The experimental and control groups were homogeneous with regard to age (mean [SD] age, 8.8 [2.5] vs 8.6 [2.2] years), sex (female, 11 [55.0%] vs 9 [45.0%]), parents' age (mean [SD] age, 41.8 [6.2] vs 41.3 [5.0] years), and previous surgical procedures (already underwent surgical procedure, 9 [45.0%] vs 10 [50.0%]). The initial mean (SD) m-YPAS scores were 37.3 (21.7) and 37.1 (13.8) for the experimental and control groups, respectively; the mean (SD) m-YPAS scores when entering the OR were 33.0 (18.4) and 48.6 (15.9), respectively (P = .009). The mean (SD) difference between the m-YPAS score at the first and second measurements of each participant was -2.8 (7.2) in the experimental group and 10.7 (10.8) in the control group. The 13.5-point difference between these averages was statistically significant (P = .003).
The app was effective in reducing preoperative anxiety in Italian children admitted to an Italian National Health System pediatric hospital and may act as a substitute for staff-provided interventions, allowing possible reductions of hospital costs.
clinicaltrials.gov Identifier: NCT01688115.
重要性:有效的方法可以减少儿童术前焦虑(如事先提供信息、在干预前组织参观手术室[OR]以及引入小丑医生),但对于一些医院来说,这些方法可能难以实施,因为它们既费时又昂贵,并且需要医院工作人员来执行。
目的:测试 Clickamico 应用程序的有效性,该应用程序展示小丑医生对 OR 进行滑稽而有趣的参观,以减少儿童的术前焦虑。
设计、地点和参与者:这是一项未设盲的随机临床试验,纳入了 2013 年 12 月至 2014 年 9 月期间在意大利一家三级儿科医院接受计划手术干预的 40 名 6 至 11 岁儿童,将他们随机分为实验组(n = 20)和对照组(n = 20)。
干预措施:实验组的干预措施是一段 6 分钟的视频,展示了 2 位小丑医生参观 OR,并以开玩笑的方式互相解释 OR 中的物品。实验组的儿童在计划手术前的下午在平板电脑上观看该视频。对照组的干预措施是第二天有关手术程序的标准信息干预。
主要结局和测量指标:主要结局是术前焦虑。术前焦虑在实验组和对照组的干预前以及进入 OR 前使用改良耶鲁术前焦虑量表(m-YPAS)进行测量。
结果:实验组和对照组在年龄(平均[标准差]年龄,8.8[2.5]岁比 8.6[2.2]岁)、性别(女性,11[55.0%]比 9[45.0%])、父母年龄(平均[标准差]年龄,41.8[6.2]岁比 41.3[5.0]岁)和之前的手术程序(已经接受过手术程序,9[45.0%]比 10[50.0%])方面具有同质性。实验组和对照组的初始 m-YPAS 平均(标准差)评分分别为 37.3(21.7)和 37.1(13.8);进入 OR 时的平均(标准差)m-YPAS 评分分别为 33.0(18.4)和 48.6(15.9)(P = .009)。实验组和对照组每位参与者的第一次和第二次测量之间的 m-YPAS 评分的平均(标准差)差异分别为-2.8(7.2)和 10.7(10.8)。这些平均值之间的 13.5 点差异具有统计学意义(P = .003)。
结论和相关性:该应用程序在减少意大利国家卫生系统儿科医院接受手术的意大利儿童的术前焦虑方面是有效的,并且可以作为工作人员提供的干预措施的替代方法,从而有可能降低医院成本。
试验注册:clinicaltrials.gov 标识符:NCT01688115。