Ravindra Vijay M, Bollo Robert J, Sivakumar Walavan, Akbari Hassan, Naftel Robert P, Limbrick David D, Jea Andrew, Gannon Stephen, Shannon Chevis, Birkas Yekaterina, Yang George L, Prather Colin T, Kestle John R, Riva-Cambrin Jay
1 Department of Neurosurgery, University of Utah School of Medicine ; Division of Pediatric Neurosurgery, Primary Children's Hospital, Salt Lake City, Utah.
2 Department of Neurosurgery, Washington University in St. Louis ; Division of Pediatric Neurosurgery, St. Louis Children's Hospital, St. Louis, Missouri.
J Neurotrauma. 2017 Jan 15;34(2):391-399. doi: 10.1089/neu.2016.4415. Epub 2016 Jul 25.
Risk factors for blunt cerebrovascular injury (BCVI) may differ between children and adults, suggesting that children at low risk for BCVI after trauma receive unnecessary computed tomography angiography (CTA) and high-dose radiation. We previously developed a score for predicting pediatric BCVI based on retrospective cohort analysis. Our objective is to externally validate this prediction score with a retrospective multi-institutional cohort. We included patients who underwent CTA for traumatic cranial injury at four pediatric Level I trauma centers. Each patient in the validation cohort was scored using the "Utah Score" and classified as high or low risk. Before analysis, we defined a misclassification rate <25% as validating the Utah Score. Six hundred forty-five patients (mean age 8.6 ± 5.4 years; 63.4% males) underwent screening for BCVI via CTA. The validation cohort was 411 patients from three sites compared with the training cohort of 234 patients. Twenty-two BCVIs (5.4%) were identified in the validation cohort. The Utah Score was significantly associated with BCVIs in the validation cohort (odds ratio 8.1 [3.3, 19.8], p < 0.001) and discriminated well in the validation cohort (area under the curve 72%). When the Utah Score was applied to the validation cohort, the sensitivity was 59%, specificity was 85%, positive predictive value was 18%, and negative predictive value was 97%. The Utah Score misclassified 16.6% of patients in the validation cohort. The Utah Score for predicting BCVI in pediatric trauma patients was validated with a low misclassification rate using a large, independent, multicenter cohort. Its implementation in the clinical setting may reduce the use of CTA in low-risk patients.
钝性脑血管损伤(BCVI)的危险因素在儿童和成人中可能有所不同,这表明创伤后BCVI低风险的儿童接受了不必要的计算机断层血管造影(CTA)和高剂量辐射。我们之前基于回顾性队列分析制定了一个预测儿童BCVI的评分系统。我们的目的是通过回顾性多机构队列对这个预测评分进行外部验证。我们纳入了在四个儿科一级创伤中心因颅脑外伤接受CTA检查的患者。验证队列中的每位患者都使用“犹他评分”进行评分,并分为高风险或低风险。在分析之前,我们将误分类率<25%定义为对犹他评分的验证。645例患者(平均年龄8.6±5.4岁;63.4%为男性)通过CTA进行了BCVI筛查。与234例患者的训练队列相比,验证队列有来自三个地点的411例患者。在验证队列中识别出22例BCVI(5.4%)。犹他评分在验证队列中与BCVI显著相关(优势比8.1[3.3,19.8],p<0.001),并且在验证队列中具有良好的区分度(曲线下面积72%)。当将犹他评分应用于验证队列时,敏感性为59%,特异性为85%,阳性预测值为18%,阴性预测值为97%。犹他评分在验证队列中对16.6%的患者进行了错误分类。使用一个大型、独立、多中心队列对预测儿科创伤患者BCVI的犹他评分进行了验证,误分类率较低。在临床环境中实施该评分系统可能会减少低风险患者CTA的使用。