Bambi Stefano, Lumini Enrico, Becattini Giovanni, Lucchini Alberto, Rasero Laura
G Ital Med Lav Ergon. 2016 Jan-Mar;38(1):50-7.
Bullying and horizontal violence are particular features of workplace violence, currently under the attention of professional organizations in the nursing world.
To highlight the spread of the phenomenon, the characteristics, consequences and possible solutions.
Literature review through Medline and CINAHL databases using the following keywords: "lateral", "horizontal", "hostility", "bullying", "workplace bullying," "violence" "nursing".
30 original studies were selected and included in the review. The prevalence of bullying variesfrom 5.7% to 94% of surveyed nurses. The horizontal violence percentages are, instead, 1.3% and 65%. Theforms of abuse experienced by nurses are rangingfrom acial harassment (lessfrequent, 4.5%), to emotional abuse (up to 62.4%) and being burdened with unmanageable workloads (71%). There is a strong correlation between poor quality of interpersonal relationships and the greater rate of abuse perpetrated by peer colleagues and supervisors. Bullying is significantly higher among those who have less seniority, and are younger. The most common problems reported by victims, range from anxiety, to headache,, gastrointestinal symptoms, and finally to those typical of post-traumatic stress disorder (from 25% to 55%). The victims of bullying have a high proportion of intent to resign (50%), and a 3-fold greater propensity than others to leave the profession (p < 0.001).
The theory Oppressed Group Behavior is the most reliable to explain bullying and horizontal violence among nurses, although currently not validated. There are difficulties in comparing the data about bullying and horizontal violence from the literature due to the lack of agreed definitions. Studies about prevention and management of problems derived from bullying and horizontal violence are still scant.
欺凌和横向暴力是工作场所暴力的特殊表现形式,目前受到护理界专业组织的关注。
强调该现象的传播、特征、后果及可能的解决办法。
通过Medline和CINAHL数据库进行文献综述,使用以下关键词:“横向的”“水平的”“敌意”“欺凌”“工作场所欺凌”“暴力”“护理”。
选取30项原创研究纳入综述。欺凌的发生率在接受调查的护士中从5.7%至94%不等。相反,横向暴力的比例为1.3%和65%。护士遭受的虐待形式从种族骚扰(较少见,4.5%)到情感虐待(高达62.4%)以及不堪重负的工作量(71%)。人际关系质量差与同事和上级实施的更高虐待率之间存在很强的相关性。资历较浅、年龄较小的人遭受欺凌的情况明显更高。受害者报告的最常见问题包括焦虑、头痛、胃肠道症状,最后是创伤后应激障碍的典型症状(25%至55%)。遭受欺凌的受害者中有很大比例打算辞职(50%),且离开该职业的倾向是其他人的3倍(p<0.001)。
受压迫群体行为理论是解释护士中欺凌和横向暴力最可靠的理论,尽管目前尚未得到验证。由于缺乏统一的定义,难以比较文献中关于欺凌和横向暴力的数据。关于欺凌和横向暴力引发问题的预防和管理的研究仍然很少。