Liu Kai, Cui Meng-Ying, Cao Peng, Wang Jiang-Bo
School of Transportation and Logistics, Dalian University of Technology, Dalian, 116024, P.R. China.
College of Science and Engineering, University of Minnesota, Twin Cities, Minneapolis, MN, 55455, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2016 Jun 30;11(6):e0158123. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0158123. eCollection 2016.
On urban arterials, travel time estimation is challenging especially from various data sources. Typically, fusing loop detector data and probe vehicle data to estimate travel time is a troublesome issue while considering the data issue of uncertain, imprecise and even conflicting. In this paper, we propose an improved data fusing methodology for link travel time estimation. Link travel times are simultaneously pre-estimated using loop detector data and probe vehicle data, based on which Bayesian fusion is then applied to fuse the estimated travel times. Next, Iterative Bayesian estimation is proposed to improve Bayesian fusion by incorporating two strategies: 1) substitution strategy which replaces the lower accurate travel time estimation from one sensor with the current fused travel time; and 2) specially-designed conditions for convergence which restrict the estimated travel time in a reasonable range. The estimation results show that, the proposed method outperforms probe vehicle data based method, loop detector based method and single Bayesian fusion, and the mean absolute percentage error is reduced to 4.8%. Additionally, iterative Bayesian estimation performs better for lighter traffic flows when the variability of travel time is practically higher than other periods.
在城市主干道上,行程时间估计颇具挑战性,尤其是面对来自各种数据源的数据时。通常,在考虑数据存在不确定性、不精确性甚至冲突性的情况下,融合环形探测器数据和探测车辆数据来估计行程时间是个棘手的问题。在本文中,我们提出了一种用于路段行程时间估计的改进数据融合方法。利用环形探测器数据和探测车辆数据同时对路段行程时间进行预估计,在此基础上应用贝叶斯融合来融合估计出的行程时间。接下来,提出了迭代贝叶斯估计,通过结合两种策略来改进贝叶斯融合:1)替换策略,即用当前融合后的行程时间替换来自一个传感器的准确性较低的行程时间估计;2)专门设计的收敛条件,将估计出的行程时间限制在合理范围内。估计结果表明,所提出的方法优于基于探测车辆数据的方法、基于环形探测器的方法和单一贝叶斯融合方法,平均绝对百分比误差降至4.8%。此外,当行程时间的变异性在实际中高于其他时段时,迭代贝叶斯估计在交通流量较小时表现更好。