Jha Vikas, Behari Sanjay, Jaiswal Awadhesh K, Bhaisora Kamlesh Singh, Shende Yogesh P, Phadke Rajendra V
Department of Neurosurgery, Sanjay Gandhi Postgraduate Institute of Medical Sciences, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh, India.
Department of Radiology, Sanjay Gandhi Postgraduate Institute of Medical Sciences, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh, India.
Asian J Neurosurg. 2016 Jul-Sep;11(3):240-54. doi: 10.4103/1793-5482.145340.
Concurrent arterial aneurysms (AAs) occurring in 2.7-16.7% patients harboring an arteriovenous malformation (AVM) aggravate the risk of intracranial hemorrhage.
We evaluate the variations of aneurysms simultaneously coexisting with AVMs. A classification-based management strategy and an abbreviated nomenclature that describes their radiological features is also proposed.
Tertiary care academic institute.
Test of significance applied to determine the factors causing rebleeding in the groups of patients with concurrent AVM and aneurysm and those with only AVMs.
Sixteen patients (5 with subarachnoid hemorrhage and 11 with intracerebral/intraventricular hemorrhage; 10 with low flow [LF] and 6 with high flow [HF] AVMs) underwent radiological assessment of Spetzler Martin (SM) grading and flow status of AA + AVM. Their modified Rankin's score (mRS) at admission was compared with their follow-up (F/U) score.
Pre-operative mRS was 0 in 5, 2 in 6, 3 in 1, 4 in 3 and 5 in 1; and, SM grade I in 5, II in 3, III in 3, IV in 4 and V in 1 patients, respectively. AA associated AVMs were classified as: (I) Flow-related proximal (n = 2); (II) flow-related distal (n = 3); (III) intranidal (n = 5); (IV) extra-intranidal (n = 2); (V) remote major ipsilateral (n = 1); (VI) remote major contralateral (n = 1); (VII) deep perforator related (n = 1); (VIII) superficial (n = 1); and (IX) distal (n = 0). Their treatment strategy included: Flow related AA, SM I-III LF AVM: aneurysm clipping with AVM excision; nidal-extranidal AA, SM I-III LF AVM: Excision or embolization of both AA + AVM; nidal-extranidal and perforator-related AA, SM IV-V HF AVM: Only endovascular embolization or radiosurgery. Surgical decision-making for remote AA took into account their ipsilateral/contralateral filling status and vessel dominance; and, for AA associated with SM III HF AVM, it varied in each patient based on diffuseness of AVM nidus, flow across arteriovenous fistula and eloquence of cortex. Follow up (F/U) (23.29 months; range: 1.5-69 months) mRS scores were 0 in 12, 2 in 2, 3 in 1 and 6 in 1 patients, respectively.
Patients with intracranial AVMs should be screened for concurrent AAs. Further grading, management protocols and prognostication should particularly "focus on the aneurysm."
在2.7%-16.7%患有动静脉畸形(AVM)的患者中并发的动脉动脉瘤(AA)会增加颅内出血的风险。
我们评估与AVM同时存在的动脉瘤的变化情况。还提出了一种基于分类的管理策略和一种描述其放射学特征的简化命名法。
三级医疗学术机构。
应用显著性检验来确定在并发AVM和动脉瘤的患者组以及仅患有AVM的患者组中导致再出血的因素。
16例患者(5例蛛网膜下腔出血,11例脑内/脑室内出血;10例低流量[LF]AVM,6例高流量[HF]AVM)接受了Spetzler Martin(SM)分级和AA + AVM血流状态的放射学评估。将他们入院时的改良Rankin评分(mRS)与其随访(F/U)评分进行比较。
术前mRS为0分的有5例,2分的有6例,3分的有1例,4分的有3例,5分的有1例;SM分级为I级的有5例,II级的有3例,III级的有3例,IV级的有4例,V级的有1例。与AA相关的AVM分类如下:(I)血流相关近端(n = 2);(II)血流相关远端(n = 3);(III)瘤巢内(n = 5);(IV)瘤巢内外(n = 2);(V)同侧远处主要血管(n = 1);(VI)对侧远处主要血管(n = 1);(VII)深部穿支相关(n = 1);(VIII)浅表(n = 1);(IX)远端(n = 0)。其治疗策略包括:血流相关AA、SM I-III级LF AVM:动脉瘤夹闭并切除AVM;瘤巢-瘤巢外AA、SM I-III级LF AVM:切除或栓塞AA + AVM;瘤巢-瘤巢外及穿支相关AA、SM IV-V级HF AVM:仅行血管内栓塞或放射外科治疗。对于远处AA的手术决策考虑其同侧/对侧充盈状态和血管优势;对于与SM III级HF AVM相关的AA,根据AVM瘤巢的弥散程度、动静脉瘘的血流情况和皮质的功能区在每个患者中有所不同。随访(F/U)(23.29个月;范围:1.5 - 69个月)mRS评分分别为0分的有12例,2分的有2例,3分的有1例,6分的有1例。
颅内AVM患者应筛查是否并发AA。进一步的分级、管理方案和预后评估应特别“关注动脉瘤”。