University of Stirling, Department of Psychology, Stirling, FK9 4LA, Scotland, United Kingdom.
McGill Vision Research, Department of Ophthalmology, McGill University, Montreal, Canada.
Sci Rep. 2016 Jul 11;6:29287. doi: 10.1038/srep29287.
The role of color in the visual perception of mirror-symmetry is controversial. Some reports support the existence of color-selective mirror-symmetry channels, others that mirror-symmetry perception is merely sensitive to color-correlations across the symmetry axis. Here we test between the two ideas. Stimuli consisted of colored Gaussian-blobs arranged either mirror-symmetrically or quasi-randomly. We used four arrangements: (1) 'segregated' - symmetric blobs were of one color, random blobs of the other color(s); (2) 'random-segregated' - as above but with the symmetric color randomly selected on each trial; (3) 'non-segregated' - symmetric blobs were of all colors in equal proportions, as were the random blobs; (4) 'anti-symmetric' - symmetric blobs were of opposite-color across the symmetry axis. We found: (a) near-chance levels for the anti-symmetric condition, suggesting that symmetry perception is sensitive to color-correlations across the symmetry axis; (b) similar performance for random-segregated and non-segregated conditions, giving no support to the idea that mirror-symmetry is color selective; (c) highest performance for the color-segregated condition, but only when the observer knew beforehand the symmetry color, suggesting that symmetry detection benefits from color-based attention. We conclude that mirror-symmetry detection mechanisms, while sensitive to color-correlations across the symmetry axis and subject to the benefits of attention-to-color, are not color selective.
颜色在镜像对称的视觉感知中的作用存在争议。一些报告支持存在颜色选择性的镜像对称通道,而另一些报告则认为镜像对称感知仅对对称轴上的颜色相关性敏感。在这里,我们对这两种观点进行了测试。刺激物由排列成镜像对称或准随机的彩色高斯斑点组成。我们使用了四种排列方式:(1)“分离”——对称的斑点是一种颜色,随机的斑点是另一种颜色;(2)“随机分离”——与上述相同,但在每次试验中随机选择对称颜色;(3)“非分离”——对称的斑点是所有颜色的等比例混合,随机的斑点也是如此;(4)“反对称”——对称的斑点在对称轴上是相反的颜色。我们发现:(a)反对称条件下的接近随机水平,表明对称感知对对称轴上的颜色相关性敏感;(b)随机分离和非分离条件下的相似表现,不支持镜像对称是颜色选择性的观点;(c)颜色分离条件下的最高表现,但只有当观察者事先知道对称颜色时,表明对称检测受益于基于颜色的注意力。我们得出结论,镜像对称检测机制虽然对对称轴上的颜色相关性敏感,并受益于对颜色的注意力,但不是颜色选择性的。