Haghighi Mohammad, Barikani Reza, Jahangard Leila, Ahmadpanah Mohammad, Bajoghli Hafez, Sadeghi Bahmani Dena, Holsboer-Trachsler Edith, Brand Serge
Research Center for Behavioral Disorders and Substance Abuse, Hamadan University of Medial Sciences, Hamadan, Iran.
Iranian National Center for Addiction Studies (INCAS), Iranian Institute for Reduction of High-Risk Behaviors, Tehran University of Medial Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
Compr Psychiatry. 2016 Aug;69:71-7. doi: 10.1016/j.comppsych.2016.05.009. Epub 2016 May 13.
There is limited evidence on the long-term outcomes for patients with bipolar I disorder (BP-I-D) and treated with ECT. Therefore, we asked whether mania scores and cognitive performance at the end of ECT treatment (baseline/BL) predicted mania scores, cognitive performance, recurrence, treatment adherence, and mood (depression; hypomania) two years later (follow-up/FU).
38 patients with BP-I-D undergoing ECT at baseline were followed up two years later. A brief psychiatric and cognitive assessment (Mini Mental State Examination; short-term verbal memory test) was performed; patients completed questionnaires covering recurrence, treatment adherence, and mood (depression; hypomania).
High cognitive performance at BL predicted high cognitive performance at FU; low mania scores at BL predicted low mania scores at FU. By FU, cognitive performance had increased and mania scores decreased. Mania scores and cognitive performance at BL did not predict recurrence, or adherence to medication, or mood (depression; hypomania).
The pattern of results suggests that after two years of successful treatment of acute mania with ECT, cognitive impairment, measured by MMSE and a short-term verbal memory test, is not impaired and mood symptom recurrence seems to be improved. Mania scores and cognitive performance at the end of ECT treatment predicted neither mood (depression; hypomania), nor recurrence, or adherence to medication two years later.
关于双相I型障碍(BP-I-D)患者接受电休克治疗(ECT)的长期预后的证据有限。因此,我们探讨了ECT治疗结束时(基线/BL)的躁狂评分和认知表现是否能预测两年后(随访/FU)的躁狂评分、认知表现、复发情况、治疗依从性和情绪(抑郁;轻躁狂)。
对38例基线时接受ECT治疗的BP-I-D患者进行了两年的随访。进行了简短的精神和认知评估(简易精神状态检查表;短期言语记忆测试);患者完成了涵盖复发、治疗依从性和情绪(抑郁;轻躁狂)的问卷。
基线时较高的认知表现预测随访时较高的认知表现;基线时较低的躁狂评分预测随访时较低的躁狂评分。到随访时,认知表现有所提高,躁狂评分有所下降。基线时的躁狂评分和认知表现不能预测复发、药物依从性或情绪(抑郁;轻躁狂)。
结果模式表明,ECT成功治疗急性躁狂两年后,通过简易精神状态检查表和短期言语记忆测试测量的认知障碍没有受损,情绪症状复发似乎有所改善。ECT治疗结束时的躁狂评分和认知表现既不能预测两年后的情绪(抑郁;轻躁狂)、复发情况,也不能预测药物依从性。