Joyce Paul, Wardle Jon, Zaslawski Chris
J Complement Integr Med. 2016 Dec 1;13(4):333-345. doi: 10.1515/jcim-2014-0053.
Background This paper aims to remedy a gap in the knowledge by presenting the first critical review of the literature on major themes relating to medical students perceptions and attitudes towards the exponentially growing field of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM). MethodsAfter a comprehensive database search of the literature, 21 papers were chosen as suitable for the review. The results from these papers were tabled and discussed. ResultsThe results indicated that medical students lacked knowledge of CAM and are generally positive towards CAM education (especially in the preclinical years, if it provided evidence of efficacy and post-placement). Medical students thought that CAM should generally be incorporated into the medical curriculum mainly so they can confidently undertake referral to CAM practitioners. Being able to communicate with future patients about their CAM use was a major motivation for medical students to learn about CAM and a factor for medical student support of further incorporation of CAM content in the medical curricula. Educational exposure to CAM in many forms and in many papers was shown to significantly affect medical student attitudes to CAM. This may be reflective of the fact that, outside direct CAM training, there may be limited accessible opportunities for medical students and if integration is to occur, educational exposure is most important. ConclusionsThe rise of CAM as a social and clinical phenomenon necessitates consideration of further inclusion of these topics in the medical curriculum, if future physicians are to be able to fully discharge their role as care providers in an increasingly medically pluralistic world. However, the inclusion of CAM needs to be done in an objective and critical manner, which is relevant to the learner.
背景 本文旨在通过对有关医学生对迅速发展的补充与替代医学(CAM)领域的认知和态度的主要主题的文献进行首次批判性综述,来弥补知识上的空白。方法 在对文献进行全面的数据库检索后,选择了21篇论文作为适合该综述的文献。将这些论文的结果制成表格并进行讨论。结果 结果表明,医学生缺乏补充与替代医学知识,并且总体上对补充与替代医学教育持积极态度(尤其是在临床前阶段,如果能提供疗效证据以及实习后的情况)。医学生认为补充与替代医学通常应纳入医学课程,主要是为了他们能够自信地向补充与替代医学从业者进行转诊。能够与未来的患者就其使用补充与替代医学的情况进行沟通,是医学生学习补充与替代医学的主要动力,也是医学生支持在医学课程中进一步纳入补充与替代医学内容的一个因素。在许多论文中,以多种形式对补充与替代医学的教育接触被证明会显著影响医学生对补充与替代医学的态度。这可能反映了这样一个事实,即在直接的补充与替代医学培训之外,医学生可获得的机会可能有限,如果要进行整合,教育接触是最重要的。结论 补充与替代医学作为一种社会和临床现象的兴起,使得如果未来的医生要在一个医学日益多元化的世界中充分履行其作为护理提供者的职责,就有必要考虑在医学课程中进一步纳入这些主题。然而,补充与替代医学的纳入需要以客观和批判性的方式进行,且要与学习者相关。