Kaimakliotis Pavlos, Simillis Constantinos, Harbord Marcus, Kontovounisios Christos, Rasheed Shahnawaz, Tekkis Paris P
*Department of Colorectal Surgery, Royal Marsden Hospital †Department of Colorectal Surgery, Chelsea & Westminster Hospital, Imperial College ‡Department of Gastroenterology, Chelsea & Westminster Hospital, London, UK.
J Clin Gastroenterol. 2016 Oct;50(9):714-21. doi: 10.1097/MCG.0000000000000607.
Rectovaginal and enterovesical fistulae are difficult to treat in patients with Crohn's disease. Currently, there is no consensus regarding their appropriate management.
The aim of the study was to review the literature on the medical management of rectovaginal and enterovesical fistulae in Crohn's disease and to assess their response to treatment.
A literature search of MEDLINE, EMBASE, Science Citation Index Expanded, and Cochrane was performed.
Twenty-three studies were identified, reporting on 137 rectovaginal and 44 enterovesical fistulae. The overall response rates of rectovaginal fistulae to medical therapy were: 38.3% complete response (fistula closure), 22.3% partial response, and 39.4% no response. For enterovesical fistulae the response rates to medical therapy were: 65.9% complete response, 20.5% partial response, and 13.6% no response. Specifically, response to anti-tumor necrosis factor therapy of 78 rectovaginal fistulae was: 41.0% complete response, 21.8% partial response, and 37.2% no response. Response of 14 enterovesical fistulae to anti-tumor necrosis factor therapy was: 57.1% complete response, 35.7% partial response, and 7.1% no response. The response to a combination of medical and surgical therapy in 43 rectovaginal fistulae was: 44.2% complete response, 20.9% partial response, and 34.9% no response.
Medical therapy, alone or in combination with surgery, appears to benefit some patients with rectovaginal or enterovesical fistula. However, given the small size and low quality of the published studies, it is still difficult to draw conclusions regarding treatment. Larger, better quality studies are required to assess response to medical treatment and evaluate indications for surgery.
克罗恩病患者的直肠阴道瘘和肠膀胱瘘难以治疗。目前,对于其恰当的治疗方法尚无共识。
本研究旨在回顾关于克罗恩病直肠阴道瘘和肠膀胱瘘药物治疗的文献,并评估其治疗反应。
对医学文献数据库(MEDLINE)、荷兰医学文摘数据库(EMBASE)、科学引文索引扩展版(Science Citation Index Expanded)和考科蓝图书馆(Cochrane)进行文献检索。
共纳入23项研究,报道了137例直肠阴道瘘和44例肠膀胱瘘。直肠阴道瘘药物治疗的总体反应率为:完全缓解(瘘管闭合)38.3%,部分缓解22.3%,无反应39.4%。肠膀胱瘘药物治疗的反应率为:完全缓解65.9%,部分缓解20.5%,无反应13.6%。具体而言,78例直肠阴道瘘对抗肿瘤坏死因子治疗的反应为:完全缓解41.0%,部分缓解21.8%,无反应37.2%。14例肠膀胱瘘对抗肿瘤坏死因子治疗的反应为:完全缓解57.1%,部分缓解35.7%,无反应7.1%。43例直肠阴道瘘采用药物联合手术治疗的反应为:完全缓解44.2%,部分缓解20.9%,无反应34.9%。
药物治疗,单独使用或与手术联合使用,似乎对一些直肠阴道瘘或肠膀胱瘘患者有益。然而,鉴于已发表研究的样本量小且质量低,仍难以得出关于治疗的结论。需要开展更大规模、更高质量的研究来评估药物治疗反应并评估手术指征。