Schur Mathew D, Andras Lindsay M, Broom Alexander M, Barrett Kody K, Bowman Christine A, Luther Herman, Goldstein Rachel Y, Fletcher Nicholas D, Millis Michael B, Runner Robert, Skaggs David L
Children's Orthopedic Center, Children's Hospital Los Angeles, Los Angeles, CA.
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Children's Healthcare of Atlanta, Atlanta, GA.
J Pediatr. 2016 Oct;177:250-254. doi: 10.1016/j.jpeds.2016.06.029. Epub 2016 Jul 26.
To evaluate whether the time from symptom onset to diagnosis of slipped capital femoral epiphysis (SCFE) has improved over a recent decade compared with reports of previous decades.
Retrospective review of 481 patients admitted with a diagnosis of SCFE at three large pediatric hospitals between January 2003 and December 2012.
The average time from symptom onset to diagnosis of SCFE was 17 weeks (range, 0-to 169). There were no significant differences in time from symptom onset to diagnosis across 2-year intervals of the 10-year study period (P = .94). The time from evaluation by first provider to diagnosis was significantly shorter for patients evaluated at an orthopedic clinic (mean, 0 weeks; range, 0-0 weeks) compared with patients evaluated by a primary care provider (mean, 4 weeks; range, 0-52 weeks; r = 0.24; P = .003) or at an emergency department (mean, 6 weeks, range, 0-104 weeks; r = 0.36; P = .008). Fifty-two patients (10.8%) developed a second SCFE after treatment of the first affected side. The time from the onset of symptoms to diagnosis for the second episode of SCFE was significantly shorter (r = 0.19; P < .001), with mean interval of 11 weeks (range, 0-104 weeks) from symptom onset to diagnosis. There were significantly more cases of mildly severe SCFE, as defined by the Wilson classification scheme, in second episodes of SCFE compared with first episodes of SCFE (OR, 4.44; P = .001).
Despite reports documenting a lag in time to the diagnosis of SCFE more than a decade ago, there has been no improvement in the speed of diagnosis. Decreases in both the time to diagnosis and the severity of findings for the second episode of SCFE suggest that the education of at-risk children and their families (or providers) may be of benefit in decreasing this delay.
评估与过去几十年的报告相比,近十年来从症状出现到诊断为股骨头骨骺滑脱(SCFE)的时间是否有所改善。
对2003年1月至2012年12月期间在三家大型儿科医院收治的481例诊断为SCFE的患者进行回顾性研究。
从症状出现到诊断为SCFE的平均时间为17周(范围为0至169周)。在10年研究期的2年间隔内,从症状出现到诊断的时间没有显著差异(P = 0.94)。与由初级保健提供者评估的患者(平均4周;范围为0至52周;r = 0.24;P = 0.003)或在急诊科评估的患者(平均6周,范围为0至104周;r = 0.36;P = 0.008)相比,在骨科诊所评估的患者从首次提供者评估到诊断的时间明显更短(平均0周;范围为0至0周)。52例患者(10.8%)在首次患侧治疗后出现了第二次SCFE。第二次SCFE发作从症状出现到诊断的时间明显更短(r = 0.19;P < 0.001),从症状出现到诊断的平均间隔为11周(范围为0至104周)。与SCFE首次发作相比,根据Wilson分类方案定义的轻度严重SCFE病例在第二次发作中明显更多(OR,4.44;P = 0.001)。
尽管有报告记录了十多年前SCFE诊断时间的延迟,但诊断速度并未得到改善。第二次SCFE发作的诊断时间和检查结果严重程度的降低表明,对高危儿童及其家庭(或提供者)进行教育可能有助于减少这种延迟。