Camp A A, Buchwalter D B
North Carolina State University, 850 Main Campus Drive Box 7633, Raleigh, NC 27695, USA.
Aquat Toxicol. 2016 Sep;178:49-57. doi: 10.1016/j.aquatox.2016.07.011. Epub 2016 Jul 19.
Neonicotinoid insecticide usage has increased globally in recent decades. Neonicotinoids, such as imidacloprid, are potent insect neurotoxicants that may pose a threat to non-target aquatic organisms, such as aquatic insects. In nature, insects typically live in thermally fluctuating conditions, which may significantly alter both contaminant exposures and affects. Here we investigate the relationship between temperature and time-to-effect for imidacloprid toxicity with the aquatic insect Isonychia bicolor, a lotic mayfly. Additionally, we examined the mechanisms driving temperature-enhanced toxicity including metabolic rate, imidacloprid uptake rate, and tissue bioconcentration. Experiments included acute toxicity tests utilizing sublethal endpoints and mortality, as well as respirometry and radiotracer assays with [(14)C] imidacloprid. Further, we conducted additional uptake experiments with a suite of aquatic invertebrates (including I. bicolor, Neocloeon triangulifer, Macaffertium modestum, Pteronarcys proteus, Acroneuria carolinensis, and Pleuroceridae sp) to confirm and contextualize our findings from initial experiments. The 96h EC50 (immobility) for I. bicolor at 15°C was 5.81μg/L which was approximately 3.2 fold lower than concentrations associated with 50% mortality. Assays examining the impact of temperature were conducted at 15, 18, 21, and 24°C and demonstrated that time-to-effect for sublethal impairment and immobility was significantly decreased with increasing temperature. Uptake experiments with [(14)C] imidacloprid revealed that initial uptake rates were significantly increased with increasing temperature for I. bicolor, as were oxygen consumption rates. Further, in the separate experiment with multiple species across temperatures 15, 20, and 25°C, we found that all the aquatic insects tested had significantly increased imidacloprid uptake with increasing temperatures, with N. triangulifer accumulating the most imidacloprid on a mass-specific basis. Our acute toxicity results highlight the importance of evaluating sublethal endpoints, as profound impairments of motor function were evident far before mortality. Further, we demonstrate that temperature is a powerful modulator of sublethal toxicity within a range of environmentally relevant temperatures, impacting both uptake rates and metabolic rates of I. bicolor. Finally, we show that temperature alters imidacloprid uptake across a range of species, highlighting the physiological variation present within aquatic invertebrate communities and the challenge associated with relying solely on surrogate species. Taken together, this research points to the need to consider the role of temperature in toxicity assessments.
近几十年来,新烟碱类杀虫剂在全球的使用量有所增加。吡虫啉等新烟碱类物质是强效昆虫神经毒剂,可能对非目标水生生物(如水生昆虫)构成威胁。在自然界中,昆虫通常生活在温度波动的环境中,这可能会显著改变污染物的暴露情况及其影响。在此,我们研究了温度与吡虫啉对水生昆虫双色伊索尼亚(一种溪流蜉蝣)毒性的效应时间之间的关系。此外,我们还研究了导致温度增强毒性的机制,包括代谢率、吡虫啉摄取率和组织生物富集。实验包括利用亚致死终点和死亡率的急性毒性试验,以及使用[¹⁴C]吡虫啉的呼吸测定和放射性示踪剂分析。此外,我们还对一组水生无脊椎动物(包括双色伊索尼亚、三角新克洛恩、适度麦卡弗蒂蜉蝣、变形石蝇、卡罗来纳石蛉和锥螺科物种)进行了额外的摄取实验,以确认并结合我们初步实验的结果。双色伊索尼亚在15°C时的96小时EC50(不动)为5.81μg/L,这比与50%死亡率相关的浓度低约3.2倍。在15、18、21和24°C下进行的温度影响测定表明,随着温度升高,亚致死损伤和不动的效应时间显著缩短。用[¹⁴C]吡虫啉进行的摄取实验表明,双色伊索尼亚的初始摄取率随着温度升高而显著增加,耗氧率也是如此。此外,在15、20和25°C不同温度下对多个物种进行的单独实验中,我们发现所有受试水生昆虫的吡虫啉摄取量都随着温度升高而显著增加,其中三角新克洛恩按质量比积累的吡虫啉最多。我们的急性毒性结果突出了评估亚致死终点的重要性,因为在死亡之前运动功能就出现了严重损伤。此外,我们证明在一系列与环境相关的温度范围内,温度是亚致死毒性的有力调节因子,会影响双色伊索尼亚的摄取率和代谢率。最后,我们表明温度会改变一系列物种对吡虫啉的摄取,突出了水生无脊椎动物群落中存在的生理差异以及仅依赖替代物种所带来的挑战。综上所述,这项研究表明在毒性评估中需要考虑温度的作用。