Abdulghani Hamza Mohammad, Haque Shafiul, Irshad Mohammad, Al-Zahrani Noor, Al-Bedaie Eman, Al-Fahad Latifah, Al-Eid Manar, Al-Mohaimeed Abdulrahman
Department of Medical Education, College of Medicine, King Saud University, Riyadh Research and Scientific Studies Unit, College of Nursing and Allied Health Sciences, Jazan University, Jazan Department of Family & Community Medicine, College of Medicine, Qassim University, Qassim, Saudi Arabia.
Medicine (Baltimore). 2016 Jul;95(30):e4400. doi: 10.1097/MD.0000000000004400.
This study explores the experiences of Saudi undergraduate medical students about intimate-area examination (IAE) and sexual history taking (SHT) skills and assesses the barriers and their impacts on students' learning. This survey-based study was performed at 2 Saudi university medical colleges and revealed that most of the students never performed IAE, that is, female breast, male genital, female genital, female pelvic, male rectal, and female rectal. We found that 42.3% students had never taken any sexual history during their course. Both, male and female students reported barriers of patient refusal, mismatched sex, cultural background, ethical factors, lack of supervision, lack of training, and lack of skills. Among the currently used pedagogical techniques, majority of the students were satisfied with real patient-based learning, followed by video and manikin-based learning. The study indicates that Saudi students do not have sufficient experience of IAE and SHT because of above-mentioned barriers along with religious issues. This study suggests that teachers provide positive support to students and that they develop novel, competent teaching-and-learning techniques to meet the skills training of students without compromising on religious, sociocultural, and ethical values of the kingdom.
本研究探讨了沙特本科医学生在私密部位检查(IAE)和性病史采集(SHT)技能方面的经历,并评估了相关障碍及其对学生学习的影响。这项基于调查的研究在沙特的两所大学医学院进行,结果显示大多数学生从未进行过IAE,即女性乳房、男性生殖器、女性生殖器、女性盆腔、男性直肠和女性直肠检查。我们发现42.3%的学生在课程学习期间从未采集过任何性病史。男女生均报告了患者拒绝、性别不匹配、文化背景、伦理因素、缺乏监督、缺乏培训和技能不足等障碍。在目前使用的教学方法中,大多数学生对基于真实患者的学习感到满意,其次是基于视频和人体模型的学习。该研究表明,由于上述障碍以及宗教问题,沙特学生在IAE和SHT方面没有足够的经验。本研究建议教师为学生提供积极支持,并开发新颖、有效的教学方法,以满足学生的技能培训需求,同时不损害该国的宗教、社会文化和伦理价值观。