Oh Pei Ying, Chadwick Stephen Mark
a School of Dentistry , The University of Manchester , JR Moore Building, Oxford Road, Manchester M13 9PL , UK.
J Orthod. 2016 Sep;43(3):202-17. doi: 10.1080/14653125.2016.1204510. Epub 2016 Aug 5.
Postgraduate orthodontic education is highly challenging. There is a lack of evidence regarding orthodontic postgraduates' perceptions of their orthodontic education in the United Kingdom. In addition, no study has been conducted to compare the postgraduate orthodontic training experience between UK trainees and international postgraduates.
(1) To investigate orthodontic UK trainees' and international postgraduates' perception and satisfaction of their orthodontic education. (2) To compare postgraduate orthodontic training experience between UK trainees and international postgraduates. (3) To compare orthodontic caseload between UK trainees and international postgraduates.
Utilizing a descriptive, cross-sectional survey, conducted through a web-based self-administered questionnaire, the sample population consisted of all 189 orthodontic postgraduates in the United Kingdom.
One hundred and twenty-five questionnaires were completed resulting in a response rate of 66.1%. All three academic years were evenly represented. Ninety five (76%) respondents rated the quality of their postgraduate orthodontic education as excellent. Over 90% of third year postgraduates felt the quality of their education was excellent. The majority of orthodontic trainees (n = 98, 78.4%) were satisfied with the number of cases. Apart from the first year postgraduates, other postgraduates regardless of UK trainee or international postgraduate status reported a high number of cases in treatment, with 45 (36%) respondents treating more patients than the recommended range of 80-120. Postgraduates' responses were less positive regarding their ability to influence the delivery of their programme, whether their programme represented value for money and the fairness of their training. Most of the respondents believed that UK trainees had an advantage in communicating with patients.
The majority of orthodontic postgraduates rated the quality of their postgraduate education as excellent. Apart from first year postgraduates, other postgraduates irrespective of UK trainee or international postgraduate status reported a high number of cases in treatment. There was no difference in caseload between UK trainee and international postgraduate groups.
研究生正畸教育极具挑战性。在英国,缺乏关于正畸研究生对其正畸教育看法的证据。此外,尚未开展研究比较英国学员与国际研究生之间的正畸研究生培训经历。
(1)调查英国正畸学员和国际研究生对其正畸教育的看法与满意度。(2)比较英国学员与国际研究生之间的正畸研究生培训经历。(3)比较英国学员与国际研究生之间的正畸病例量。
采用基于网络的自填式问卷进行描述性横断面调查,样本包括英国所有189名正畸研究生。
共完成125份问卷,回复率为66.1%。三个学年的代表比例均衡。95名(76%)受访者将其研究生正畸教育质量评为优秀。超过90%的三年级研究生认为其教育质量优秀。大多数正畸学员(n = 98,78.4%)对病例数量感到满意。除一年级研究生外,其他研究生无论英国学员或国际研究生身份,均报告有大量治疗病例,45名(36%)受访者治疗的患者数量超过推荐范围80 - 120例。研究生对其影响课程设置、课程是否物有所值以及培训公平性的能力的反馈不太积极。大多数受访者认为英国学员在与患者沟通方面具有优势。
大多数正畸研究生将其研究生教育质量评为优秀。除一年级研究生外,其他研究生无论英国学员或国际研究生身份,均报告有大量治疗病例。英国学员组和国际研究生组的病例量没有差异。