Devue Christel, Barsics Catherine
Department of Psychology, University of Liège, Belgium; Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience Lab, School of Psychology, Victoria University of Wellington, New Zealand.
Department of Psychology, University of Liège, Belgium; Cognitive Psychopathology and Neuropsychology Unit, University of Geneva, Switzerland; Swiss Center for Affective Sciences, University of Geneva, Switzerland.
Vision Res. 2016 Oct;127:92-103. doi: 10.1016/j.visres.2016.07.007. Epub 2016 Aug 12.
Most humans seem to demonstrate astonishingly high levels of skill in face processing if one considers the sophisticated level of fine-tuned discrimination that face recognition requires. However, numerous studies now indicate that the ability to process faces is not as fundamental as once thought and that performance can range from despairingly poor to extraordinarily high across people. Here we studied people who are super specialists of faces, namely portrait artists, to examine how their specific visual experience with faces relates to a range of face processing skills (perceptual discrimination, short- and longer term recognition). Artists show better perceptual discrimination and, to some extent, recognition of newly learned faces than controls. They are also more accurate on other perceptual tasks (i.e., involving non-face stimuli or mental rotation). By contrast, artists do not display an advantage compared to controls on longer term face recognition (i.e., famous faces) nor on person recognition from other sensorial modalities (i.e., voices). Finally, the face inversion effect exists in artists and controls and is not modulated by artistic practice. Advantages in face processing for artists thus seem to closely mirror perceptual and visual short term memory skills involved in portraiture.
如果考虑到人脸识别所需的精细辨别水平,大多数人似乎在面部处理方面展现出了惊人的高超技能。然而,现在大量研究表明,处理面部的能力并不像曾经认为的那样基础,而且不同人在这方面的表现差异极大,从极其糟糕到非常出色都有。在此,我们研究了面部超级专家,即肖像画家,以探究他们对面部的特定视觉体验与一系列面部处理技能(感知辨别、短期和长期识别)之间的关系。与对照组相比,艺术家在感知辨别方面表现更佳,并且在某种程度上,对新学面孔的识别能力也更强。他们在其他感知任务(即涉及非面部刺激或心理旋转的任务)中也更准确。相比之下,在长期面部识别(即名人面孔)以及从其他感官模态(即声音)进行人物识别方面,艺术家与对照组相比并无优势。最后,艺术家和对照组都存在面部倒置效应,且不受艺术实践的调节。因此,艺术家在面部处理方面的优势似乎紧密反映了肖像画中所涉及的感知和视觉短期记忆技能。