Wannemueller André, Appelbaum David, Küppers Maike, Matten Amelie, Teismann Tobias, Adolph Dirk, Margraf Jürgen
Mental Health Research and Treatment Center, Department of Clinical Psychology, Ruhr-Universität Bochum Bochum, Germany.
Front Psychol. 2016 Aug 9;7:1183. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2016.01183. eCollection 2016.
A large group one-session exposure treatment (LG-OST) based on indirect modeled exposure strategies was carried out to investigate its feasibility and effectiveness in a sample of highly spider fearful individuals (N = 78). The stability of LG-OST-effects was assessed at 8-month follow-up (FU). Furthermore, a second sample (N = 30) of highly spider fearful individuals was treated in a standard, single-person one-session treatment (SP-OST) design to compare LG-OST-effects to a standard spider fear treatment. Participants' fear of spider was assessed by multiple questionnaires and by a behavioral approach test. The fear assessment took place before and after the respective intervention, and at 8-month FU in LG-OST. Regarding subjective spider fear measures, LG-OST mainly showed medium to large effect sizes, ranging from Cohen's d = 0.69 to d = 1.21, except for one small effect of d = 0.25. After LG-OST, participants approached the spider closer at post-treatment measures (d = 1.18). LG-OST-effects remained stable during the 8-month FU-interval. However, SP-OST-effects proved superior in most measures. An LG-OST-protocol provided evidence for feasibility and efficiency. The effects of LG-OST were equal to those of indirect modeled exposure strategies, carried out in single-settings. LG-OST may represent a useful tool in future phobia-treatment, especially if it can match the effects of single-setting OST, e.g., by including more direct exposure elements in future large group attempts.
基于间接模拟暴露策略开展了一项针对大量人群的单次暴露治疗(LG-OST),以调查其在高度害怕蜘蛛的个体样本(N = 78)中的可行性和有效性。在8个月随访(FU)时评估LG-OST效应的稳定性。此外,对另一个高度害怕蜘蛛的个体样本(N = 30)采用标准的单人单次治疗(SP-OST)设计进行治疗,以将LG-OST效应与标准的蜘蛛恐惧治疗进行比较。通过多份问卷和行为方法测试评估参与者对蜘蛛的恐惧。恐惧评估在各自干预前后以及LG-OST的8个月随访时进行。关于主观的蜘蛛恐惧测量,LG-OST主要显示出中等到较大的效应量,范围从科恩d值 = 0.69到d = 1.21,但有一个d = 0.25的小效应除外。LG-OST治疗后,参与者在治疗后测量中更接近蜘蛛(d = 1.18)。LG-OST效应在8个月的随访期内保持稳定。然而,在大多数测量中,SP-OST效应被证明更优。一份LG-OST方案提供了可行性和有效性的证据。LG-OST的效果与在单一环境中实施的间接模拟暴露策略的效果相当。LG-OST可能是未来恐惧症治疗中的一种有用工具,特别是如果它能够在未来的大型团体尝试中通过纳入更多直接暴露元素来达到与单一环境单次治疗(OST)相同的效果。