Harris Martine Ann, Snaith Beverly, Clarke Ruth
1 Radiology, Mid Yorkshire Hospitals NHS Trust, Wakefield, UK.
Br J Radiol. 2016 Nov;89(1067):20160077. doi: 10.1259/bjr.20160077. Epub 2016 Sep 14.
To identify current UK screening practices prior to contrast-enhanced CT. To determine the patient management strategies to minimize the risk of contrast-induced acute kidney injury (CI-AKI) risk in outpatients.
An invitation to complete an electronic survey was distributed to the CT managers of 174 UK adult National Health Service hospital trusts. The survey included questions related to local protocols and national guidance on which these are based. Details of the assessment of renal function prior to imaging and thresholds for contrast contraindication and patient management were also sought.
A response rate of 47.1% was received. Almost all sites had a policy in place for contrast administration (n = 80/82; 97.6%). The majority of sites require a blood test on outpatients undergoing a contrast-enhanced CT scan (n = 75/82; 91.5%); however, some (15/75; 20.0%) sites only check the result in patients at high risk and a small number (7/82; 8.5%) of sites indicated that it was a referrer responsibility. The estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) or serum creatinine (SCr) result threshold at which i.v. contrast was contraindicated varied and 19 different threshold levels of eGFR or SCr were identified, each leading to different prophylactic strategies. Inconsistency was noted in the provision of follow-up blood tests after contrast administration.
The wide variation in practice reflects inconsistencies in published guidance. Evidence-based consensuses of which patients to test and subsequent risk thresholds will aid clinicians identify those patients in which the risk of CI-AKI is clinically significant but manageable. There is also a need to determine the value of the various prophylactic strategies, follow-up regimen and efficient service delivery pathways. Advances in knowledge: This survey has identified that further work is required to define which patients are high risk, confirm those which require renal function testing prior to contrast administration and how best to manage patients at risk of CI-AKI. The role of new technologies within this service delivery pathway requires further investigation.
确定英国目前在增强CT检查前的筛查做法。确定患者管理策略,以将门诊患者对比剂诱导的急性肾损伤(CI-AKI)风险降至最低。
向174家英国成人国民健康服务医院信托机构的CT管理人员发送了一份完成电子调查问卷的邀请。该调查包括与当地方案以及这些方案所依据的国家指南相关的问题。还询问了成像前肾功能评估的细节、对比剂禁忌的阈值以及患者管理情况。
收到了47.1%的回复率。几乎所有机构都有对比剂给药政策(n = 80/82;97.6%)。大多数机构要求对接受增强CT扫描的门诊患者进行血液检查(n = 75/82;91.5%);然而,一些机构(15/75;20.0%)仅在高危患者中检查结果,少数机构(7/82;8.5%)表示这是转诊医生的职责。静脉注射对比剂禁忌时的估计肾小球滤过率(eGFR)或血清肌酐(SCr)结果阈值各不相同,共确定了19种不同的eGFR或SCr阈值水平,每种阈值都导致不同的预防策略。对比剂给药后随访血液检查的提供情况存在不一致。
实践中的广泛差异反映了已发表指南中的不一致。关于哪些患者需要检测以及后续风险阈值的循证共识将有助于临床医生识别那些CI-AKI风险具有临床意义但可管理的患者。还需要确定各种预防策略、随访方案和高效服务提供途径的价值。知识进展:本次调查已确定需要进一步开展工作,以明确哪些患者为高危患者,确认哪些患者在对比剂给药前需要进行肾功能检测,以及如何最好地管理有CI-AKI风险的患者。新技术在这一服务提供途径中的作用需要进一步研究。